PGM Batman 181

[Cascaders27]

I'm still working on spotting flaws and then how those add up to grading so I'd appreciate some input on this one. The centerfold is intact and I'd put it at probably W/OW pages.

 

 

 

 

Thanks!

[TheMightyJohn]

7.0/7.5

 

Very nice book!

[FineCollector]

Don't start by counting the flaws, look at the overall appeal of the book and decide on the major grade. Is it in the range of VG? F? VF? Then decide how nice an example of that grade it is. What's the major grade on this one?

[etanick]

i see 5.5

 

that long vertical crease on Robin by itself might get the book 6.5 but once you add the corner crease and then the other vertical crease by the spine, then I don't see how the book can get a 6.0

[Crimebuster]

5.0

[Cascaders27]

I started off putting it somewhere between 6.0 and 7.0 which I know is rather broad but I'm just using that as a range. The two long creases down the front of the cover and that lower corner are my main concerns but the spine looks a little rough as well - and I'm unsure how much that counts against the grade here.

 

I see some creases on the back of the spine that look like they could probably be pressed and I wonder what a cleaning would do as well. My best guess puts it at 6.0 but I surely appreciate more eyes looking it over. I'm still pleased with it regardless and feel I got an alright deal

[ss5rmp]

i see a 5.0 with very nice appeal

[Boozad]

5.0

[divad]

Agreed, 5.0 plain and simple

[Cascaders27]

i see a 5.0 with very nice appeal

 

Is it nice enough to earn a shiny sticker?

 

In all seriousness I can live with even a 5.0. I bought it as a VG+ and thought it looked at least a little better than that so I'm still happy relative to what I paid. These mid-range ones confuse me about where exactly to place them so I really appreciate the comments.

[toyman-migration]

5.0

[Hado]

5.0/5.5

[Jester Hats]

5.5 - 6.0

[The-Collector]

5.0