PGM: Amazing Adventure 4 & 5

[airwalker]

Amazing Adventure #4: long crease top right corner, horizontal crease bottom part of book, 3/4 inch tear BC edge, glossy.

 

 

 

Amazing Adventure #5: 1 inch crease top right corner of FC, 1.5 to 2 inch creases bottom right corner, water stain on middle of spine FC, BC and edge. glossy

 

 

 

[toyman-migration]

2.5, 4.0

[Hado]

2.5/3.0 and 4.0/4.5

[Gibberish]

4.0/5.0

 

I am still confused on grading.

When people make a grade and I check past books with the same grade it seems that there is a big variance to me. What am I missing ?

 

 

 

When I compare the Ops book with this book, I still feel a 3.5/4.0 is closer to accurate with a decent shot at a 4.0

 

Help me to see what I am not understanding,please

To me the OP's 1st book is a LOT better in condition. I understand it has chipping and a tear,but it doesn't have a hole and water stains that look like they are filled with black mold

[zosocane]

4.0 (4.5 if not for the tear on the back) and 3.5 (5.0 if not for the water damage on the front and back).

[ryanmadam]

3.5, 2.0