PGM: All Star Western # 10

[THB]

Here are some scans. I am not too sure how much CGC hammers copys with these defects. The most glaring ones are the missing chips on the lower right hand bottom and the middle spine between DC and All in the title. Other than that I like the way the book presents and I am sending it anyways.

Thanks!!

Anthony

 

 

[Hado]

5.0/5.5

[Spiderphill]

really that low? I cant see anything knocking it under 7.0

[Crimebuster]

really that low? I cant see anything knocking it under 7.0

 

I'm not sure on this one. It does present nicely, but it has tanning around the edges on both the front and back cover. The top back edge of the book looks to me like it's maybe even a little bit brittle (the scan is upside down, so it's the edge on the bottom I am talking about). I'm no expert on CGC's handling of tanning, but from what I've read in other threads, they can be pretty harsh. I know I have a book I thought had a chance at 7.5 and it came back 6.5 mainly because of some tanning, which was lighter than this.

 

I''ll go 5.5/6.0 myself. But I don't rightly know how CGC will view it. I suspect it will present extremely well for its technical grade.

[Hado]

really that low? I cant see anything knocking it under 7.0

technically I agree, but the tanning is pretty extensive, and like crime buster said, it looks a little brittle.

 

I'd still think 5.5, the 5.0 may be too low.

[The-Collector]

Sans tanning it looks 8.0ish with the tanning I am thinking 6.0.

[Spiderphill]

Tanning and all. I say 7.0 to 7.5

[Crimebuster]

As it happens, I own a CGC 7.0 All-Star Western #10. My scans were kind of bad because I scanned it inside the mylar, but here's the PGM thread I did for mine, if anybody is interested in a comparison:

 

http://boards.collectors-society.com/ubbthreads.php?ubb=showflat&Number=5478359

 

 

[etanick]

i think 7.0 is doable.

[Hado]

As it happens, I own a CGC 7.0 All-Star Western #10. My scans were kind of bad because I scanned it inside the mylar, but here's the PGM thread I did for mine, if anybody is interested in a comparison:

 

http://boards.collectors-society.com/ubbthreads.php?ubb=showflat&Number=5478359

 

structurally they're similar, I guess it depends on CGC for the tanning.

[oakman29]

Has anybody even noticed the lower right corner,front cover is missing?

[Conan_Aficionado]

The few books that I have that possess chipping on the spine and this grade of tanning have exhibited slightly brittle edges and spine.

 

5.0/5.5

[Hado]

Has anybody even noticed the lower right corner,front cover is missing?

yes, I noticed it when comparing the two copies.

[toyman-migration]

5.0

[THB]

Thanks for the input guys.