PGM Journey Into Mystery 86

[airwalker]

Obvious defect is the smoke stains.

 

[AJD]

I'm not sure that's a smoke stain. It looks like an especially heavy oxidation or 'dust' shadow (which isn't actually caused by dust). Pity, because it's otherwise a nice book.

 

Given that CGC don't seem to hit shadows like that too hard, I'd hazard a guess that your book might still score a fine(ish) grade--5.5 to 6.0. Others might know better than me though.

[ARK]

I'm with Andrew's 5.5/6.0.

[TheMightyJohn]

4.5 for me

[comicjack]

Give it a 5.0 with the smoke.

[rjpb]

Whatever the stain is, it's pretty dark. The books looks structurally solid otherwise, but I'd have a hard time considering it any more than a 4.0/4.5 with that notable a stain. CGC may disagree.