• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Green + yellow = ?

Started by 1dingo,

49 posts in this topic

1dingo

1dingo

Posted
Posted

On another impulsive buy I got a green label comic (pages upside down) it's a 9.8 and thinking about getting it signed. What would CGC do? Does a authenticated signature outweigh an error? I would like a yellow label with the discription of error. Idk.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
mschmidt

mschmidt

Posted
Posted

There's no such thing as a yellow/green label :makepoint:

 

If a qualified book gets SS'ed, it'll end up in a yellow label with the qualifying defect now affecting the grade - for a previously qualified book with a physical defect (like a missing coupon, a back cover tear, or a missing page) you're looking at a huge grade drop.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
seanfingh

seanfingh

Posted
Posted
I saw the yellow purple hybrid one one their site but haven't seen the yellow/green one yet. Thanks for the input.

 

There is no yellow/green. The yellow label is a qualified label. The book will get a yellow label with a grade drop for whatever caused it to be in a green label.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Aces

Aces

Posted
Posted
There's no such thing as a yellow/green label :makepoint:

 

If a qualified book gets SS'ed, it'll end up in a yellow label with the qualifying defect now affecting the grade - for a previously qualified book with a physical defect (like a missing coupon, a back cover tear, or a missing page) you're looking at a huge grade drop.

Then that's pure discrimination against green. :sick:

Link to comment
Share on other sites
DiceX

DiceX

Posted
Posted
There's no such thing as a yellow/green label :makepoint:

 

If a qualified book gets SS'ed, it'll end up in a yellow label with the qualifying defect now affecting the grade - for a previously qualified book with a physical defect (like a missing coupon, a back cover tear, or a missing page) you're looking at a huge grade drop.

Then that's pure discrimination against green. :sick:

 

No. The yellow label is basically the same as a green label. It gives the grade of the book minus the one obvious significant flaw.

If the book is green and gets SS, the yellow is given for the signature flaw but the other flaw falls into the grade on the label.

 

Else they could have rainbow colored labels and every book gets graded 10.0 and the number of colors determine how low the grade "would have been" without the various flaws.

 

You can't have your cake and eat it too.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Boozad

Boozad

Posted
Posted
I saw the yellow purple hybrid one one their site but haven't seen the yellow/green one yet. Thanks for the input.

 

There is no yellow/green. The yellow label is a qualified label. The book will get a yellow label with a grade drop for whatever caused it to be in a green label.

 

How do the pages being upside down affect the grade?

Link to comment
Share on other sites
1dingo

1dingo

Posted
  • Author
Posted
I saw the yellow purple hybrid one one their site but haven't seen the yellow/green one yet. Thanks for the input.

 

There is no yellow/green. The yellow label is a qualified label. The book will get a yellow label with a grade drop for whatever caused it to be in a green label.

 

How do the pages being upside down affect the grade?

 

I don't think it affected the grading much cause it's a 9.8 just got the green label for a

Manufacturing error. Has anyone ever seen a green label higher then 9.8?

Link to comment
Share on other sites
seanfingh

seanfingh

Posted
Posted
I saw the yellow purple hybrid one one their site but haven't seen the yellow/green one yet. Thanks for the input.

 

There is no yellow/green. The yellow label is a qualified label. The book will get a yellow label with a grade drop for whatever caused it to be in a green label.

 

How do the pages being upside down affect the grade?

 

I have no idea, but I wouldn't risk it, personally.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
ChrisInBaltimore

ChrisInBaltimore

Posted
Posted
I saw the yellow purple hybrid one one their site but haven't seen the yellow/green one yet. Thanks for the input.

 

There is no yellow/green. The yellow label is a qualified label. The book will get a yellow label with a grade drop for whatever caused it to be in a green label.

 

How do the pages being upside down affect the grade?

 

I don't think it affected the grading much cause it's a 9.8 just got the green label for a

Manufacturing error. Has anyone ever seen a green label higher then 9.8?

 

It got a green label? I thought Manufacturing errors were just noted on the slab. I know I saw a book somewhere else. This seems odd to me...

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Boozad

Boozad

Posted
Posted
I saw the yellow purple hybrid one one their site but haven't seen the yellow/green one yet. Thanks for the input.

 

There is no yellow/green. The yellow label is a qualified label. The book will get a yellow label with a grade drop for whatever caused it to be in a green label.

 

How do the pages being upside down affect the grade?

 

I don't think it affected the grading much cause it's a 9.8 just got the green label for a

Manufacturing error. Has anyone ever seen a green label higher then 9.8?

 

The green label means the book isn't a 9.8 because of the defect. I want to know how CGC would grade a book universally with upside down pages.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
mschmidt

mschmidt

Posted
Posted
I saw the yellow purple hybrid one one their site but haven't seen the yellow/green one yet. Thanks for the input.

 

There is no yellow/green. The yellow label is a qualified label. The book will get a yellow label with a grade drop for whatever caused it to be in a green label.

 

How do the pages being upside down affect the grade?

 

I don't think it affected the grading much cause it's a 9.8 just got the green label for a

Manufacturing error. Has anyone ever seen a green label higher then 9.8?

 

You're missing the point about green labels. Books in qualified slabs are graded as if the qualifying defect doesn't exist - that's the sole reason why your book is a 9.8.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
seanfingh

seanfingh

Posted
Posted
I saw the yellow purple hybrid one one their site but haven't seen the yellow/green one yet. Thanks for the input.

 

There is no yellow/green. The yellow label is a qualified label. The book will get a yellow label with a grade drop for whatever caused it to be in a green label.

 

How do the pages being upside down affect the grade?

 

I don't think it affected the grading much cause it's a 9.8 just got the green label for a

Manufacturing error. Has anyone ever seen a green label higher then 9.8?

 

The green label means the book isn't a 9.8 because of the defect. I want to know how CGC would grade a book universally with upside down pages.

 

Want in one hand and mess in the other. Let me know which one gets filled up first.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Boozad

Boozad

Posted
Posted
I saw the yellow purple hybrid one one their site but haven't seen the yellow/green one yet. Thanks for the input.

 

There is no yellow/green. The yellow label is a qualified label. The book will get a yellow label with a grade drop for whatever caused it to be in a green label.

 

How do the pages being upside down affect the grade?

 

I don't think it affected the grading much cause it's a 9.8 just got the green label for a

Manufacturing error. Has anyone ever seen a green label higher then 9.8?

 

The green label means the book isn't a 9.8 because of the defect. I want to know how CGC would grade a book universally with upside down pages.

 

Want in one hand and mess in the other. Let me know which one gets filled up first.

 

'Twas only a passing interest, I'm not that interested. Although I do think I want more than I could mess. And yes that's probably debatable.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Kevin.J

Kevin.J

Posted
Posted
On another impulsive buy I got a green label comic (pages upside down) it's a 9.8 and thinking about getting it signed. What would CGC do? Does a authenticated signature outweigh an error? I would like a yellow label with the discription of error. Idk.

 

Its clever how they know its the pages that are upside down, the pages might be the right way around and the cover may be upside down (:

Then the pages would have to be back to front :ohnoez:

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Johnny U

Johnny U

Posted
Posted
On another impulsive buy I got a green label comic (pages upside down) it's a 9.8 and thinking about getting it signed. What would CGC do? Does a authenticated signature outweigh an error? I would like a yellow label with the discription of error. Idk.

 

Its clever how they know its the pages that are upside down, the pages might be the right way around and the cover may be upside down (:

Then the pages would have to be back to front :ohnoez:

:applause:

Link to comment
Share on other sites
1dingo

1dingo

Posted
  • Author
Posted
On another impulsive buy I got a green label comic (pages upside down) it's a 9.8 and thinking about getting it signed. What would CGC do? Does a authenticated signature outweigh an error? I would like a yellow label with the discription of error. Idk.

 

Its clever how they know its the pages that are upside down, the pages might be the right way around and the cover may be upside down (:

Then the pages would have to be back to front :ohnoez:

 

I left out the detail about the pages being upside down and BACKWARDS just to see if someone would catch that. (:)

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Kevin.J

Kevin.J

Posted
Posted
On another impulsive buy I got a green label comic (pages upside down) it's a 9.8 and thinking about getting it signed. What would CGC do? Does a authenticated signature outweigh an error? I would like a yellow label with the discription of error. Idk.

 

Its clever how they know its the pages that are upside down, the pages might be the right way around and the cover may be upside down (:

Then the pages would have to be back to front :ohnoez:

 

I left out the detail about the pages being upside down and BACKWARDS just to see if someone would catch that. (:)

 

:acclaim:

Link to comment
Share on other sites
seanfingh

seanfingh

Posted
Posted
I saw the yellow purple hybrid one one their site but haven't seen the yellow/green one yet. Thanks for the input.

 

There is no yellow/green. The yellow label is a qualified label. The book will get a yellow label with a grade drop for whatever caused it to be in a green label.

 

How do the pages being upside down affect the grade?

 

I don't think it affected the grading much cause it's a 9.8 just got the green label for a

Manufacturing error. Has anyone ever seen a green label higher then 9.8?

 

The green label means the book isn't a 9.8 because of the defect. I want to know how CGC would grade a book universally with upside down pages.

 

Want in one hand and mess in the other. Let me know which one gets filled up first.

 

'Twas only a passing interest, I'm not that interested. Although I do think I want more than I could mess. And yes that's probably debatable.

 

Nice Batman 4

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Go to topic listing