ROUND 5 : Contest

[supapimp]

8.5!?! ACES put the pipe down. i gave the grade away for 10 minutes before editing my post due to sensitivity.

[osborn_fr]

A generous 9.4

9.2 with that back cover

[greggy]

A generous 9.4

9.2 with that back cover

[supapimp]

not really...it's nicer than my 9.2 copy.

[nik]

A generous 9.4

9.2 with that back cover

 

I cant win here

[blutobc]

A generous 9.4

9.2 with that back cover

 

O_F we'll just have to start adding 0.5 to our guesses. We've been consistently low...too bad I don't have any books for sale right now, folks would be able to make a little money off my grading.

[Samurai-Bill]

Noooooooooooooooooooooo !!

 

9.4 .

[divad]

A generous 9.4

9.2 with that back cover

 

I cant win here

 

Niko - remember the grading thread mantra (therapy) "I am not my books . . . I am not my books . . . I am not my books"

 

[sterlingcomics]

Excelleeennttt...

[Aces]

8.5!?! ACES put the pipe down. i gave the grade away for 10 minutes before editing my post due to sensitivity.

 

 

So I listen to my best grader, who had 3 points in the first 4 rounds and was never off by more than one notch and hit the last two on the nose, and look what happens.

 

We all thought 9.0/9.2 but he says 8.0 so we went with 8.5.

[Warlord]

Another round, another half point.

[uclapeterg]

8.5!?! ACES put the pipe down. i gave the grade away for 10 minutes before editing my post due to sensitivity.

 

 

So I listen to my best grader, who had 3 points in the first 4 rounds and was never off by more than one notch and hit the last two on the nose, and look what happens.

 

We all thought 9.0/9.2 but he says 8.0 so we went with 8.5.

 

I say downgrade him to private.

[supapimp]

actually i didn't know the grade of the book, i just graded what i saw and posted it. who's on your team again?

[Aces]

8.5!?! ACES put the pipe down. i gave the grade away for 10 minutes before editing my post due to sensitivity.

 

 

So I listen to my best grader, who had 3 points in the first 4 rounds and was never off by more than one notch and hit the last two on the nose, and look what happens.

 

We all thought 9.0/9.2 but he says 8.0 so we went with 8.5.

 

I say downgrade him to private.

 

I just promoted him to full Lieutenant after round four!

But I guess your job as first mate is still safe after this round.

 

He'll have to do the push-ups this time!

[Aces]

actually i didn't know the grade of the book, i just graded what i saw and posted it. who's on your team again?

 

Aces

uclapeterg

thanos_oftitan

ImageMask

[divad]

8.5!?! ACES put the pipe down. i gave the grade away for 10 minutes before editing my post due to sensitivity.

 

 

So I listen to my best grader, who had 3 points in the first 4 rounds and was never off by more than one notch and hit the last two on the nose, and look what happens.

 

We all thought 9.0/9.2 but he says 8.0 so we went with 8.5.

 

I say downgrade him to private.

 

I just promoted him to full Lieutenant after round four!

But I guess your job as first mate is still safe after this round.

 

He'll have to do the push-ups this time!

 

Dissention in the ranks???

[ImageMask]

 

Dissention in the ranks???

 

Negative. The ranks concur on mutiny.

[Aces]

Dissention in the ranks???

 

Our swift boat hit a mine and we are taking on water badly...

[Aces]

 

Dissention in the ranks???

 

Negative. The ranks concur on mutiny.

 

 

None of us are shinning too brightly.

[ImageMask]

 

Dissention in the ranks???

 

Negative. The ranks concur on mutiny.

 

 

None of us are shinning too brightly.

 

Agreed. Was a attempt at humor that went over much like our grading.