GRADE IN - PGM Marvel Premiere #2

[DavidTheDavid]

So in my new quest for all things Warlock...well, for some things Warlock...I acquired this. Now that it's here, I see it's from the same collection as something I got before through this vendor, which came back graded far below what was claimed. I'm still on the learning curve for grading books accurately, but I was surprised that that prior book came back graded as it did. Regardless, it has me curious about this Marvel Premiere #2. And this is a great forum for me to improve my grading chops.

 

What would you folks assign this book? Thanks in advance for your input.

 

FRONT - Hi Res

REAR - Hi Res

 

[GLCBrad]

To me a 9.0/9.2 or could be better

[Mystafo]

8.5 conservatively, pending bigger scans...

[vaillant]

To me a 9.0/9.2 or could be better

 

+1, if there aren’t big issues it looks like a NM. Bigger, less contrasted scans would help a lot.

[timfinz]

I'm thinking 9.2 for your book! Presents really well. The scans are a little difficult view and a little on the small side!

[DavidTheDavid]

Purchased as 9.4 from Metropolis Comics, went straight to CGC, came back as a 9.4.

[timfinz]

Purchased as 9.4 from Metropolis Comics, went straight to CGC, came back as a 9.4.

Congratulations! Yay! I mean Ohhh so close!