Please grade this tomato boxer: Iron Man #33

[divad]

 

 

 

 

[stynxno]

8.5

[nik]

8.5

 

Agree

[Silver Surfer]

Too bad about the corner but I would still give this a 9.0.

[eddly]

9.2

[jimm94]

I'm thinking 9.0 due to the relative softness of all four corners. That could be a result of JPEG artifacting, so I could see it maybe getting 9.2 if they appear sharper in hand.

[divad]

I'm thinking 9.0 due to the relative softness of all four corners. That could be a result of JPEG artifacting, so I could see it maybe getting 9.2 if they appear sharper in hand.

 

Hey Jimm,

 

No, I think you're right there, they are not "razor-sharp". I must comment however, that the "crease" all of the others have so severly deducted for is the lightest of lines you can possibly have. If it were anywhere else but a corner, you would not call it a crease.

 

This is a perfect example of how scans are deceptive.

[Aces]

9.0

 

But I wouldn't rule out 9.2...

[FFB]

I'm thinking 9.0 due to the relative softness of all four corners. That could be a result of JPEG artifacting, so I could see it maybe getting 9.2 if they appear sharper in hand.

 

Hey Jimm,

 

No, I think you're right there, they are not "razor-sharp". I must comment however, that the "crease" all of the others have so severly deducted for is the lightest of lines you can possibly have. If it were anywhere else but a corner, you would not call it a crease.

 

This is a perfect example of how scans are deceptive.

 

I would say 9.0 from what I can see. Looks like it still has excellent gloss, too. Nice one!