PGM X-Men 54

[JLawler]

Hello all,

 

PGM X-Men 54. My last for the night and I have some high hopes for this book. 9.2-9.4, maybe 9.6. Of course, I don't have andy real experience on grading. just trying to pick up the skill. Thanks again.

 

 

[timfinz]

Your front cover scan is cropped at the bottom. You should re-scan it if you can.

There is a colour breaking crease on the front cover upper right hand corner. The upper left hand corner shows impact damage as does the lower right hand corner on the back cover. You also have numerous spine stresses. This book would probably grade around 7.5 IMHO!

[The-Collector]

Yeah 9.6 is never going to happen. There is a 2cm tear on the BC, I can also see 15 ticks on the BC, foxing lower left corner BC, edge wear right top corner both edges FC, bend/fold in marvel box FC, ticks on the FC though these are not as bad as the FC.

 

Looks 8.0/8.5 to me.

[JLawler]

Thanks guys. On the BC, if you mean at the top, it is just masking tape holding yellow paper on the upper part of my scanner. No tear on this book. I'm guessing that doesn't change opinions, but let me know if it does.

 

Thanks again for the input.

[Lost]

the dog ear corner in the top right is enough to keep this around 7.5/8 for me. great color book though!

[The-Collector]

Thanks guys. On the BC, if you mean at the top, it is just masking tape holding yellow paper on the upper part of my scanner. No tear on this book. I'm guessing that doesn't change opinions, but let me know if it does.

 

Thanks again for the input.

 

The tear I am talking about is on the back cover open edge about half way up.

[JLawler]

Got it. Thanks.