PGM: X-Men 56 and X-Men 60

[Lukas]

Hi Again!

 

after a sugesstion of max 2 books per day - i started a new topic:) still learning:)

 

Here are two nice X-Men books. I would give them a strong 8.0 or 8.5... How do You think?

 

 

 

 

 

[timfinz]

X-men #56 = 6.5 IMHO! If that is a tear on the top of the back cover?

If that is not a tear then I would go 7.5!

 

X-men #60 = 7.5 IMHO! The CB crease on the front cover LRHC is what in my opinion prevents it from grading higher!

 

These are really nice books Lukas and CGC might be more forgiving than any of the boardies here including me!

[Lukas]

Great Thanks Timern!

 

thank God it's not a tear on 56 Back! I bought them for some shop in US with grading 8.0/8.5. Hmm..

 

but 7.5 it's still nice!

[timfinz]

Great Thanks Timern!

 

thank God it's not a tear on 56 Back! I bought them for some shop in US with grading 8.0/8.5. Hmm..

 

but 7.5 it's still nice!

Remember I'm only looking at a scan so don't always go by what we grade here. Look at some of the other posts where people have asked for grades and then submitted their books to CGC and see the difference in the PGM graders scores and the CGC grades.

Check out the Harley Quinn #1 grades as posted here and see what I mean:

Harely Quinn #1

[Lukas]

Yeah i knw what You mean:) but as i am selling them - i preffer to downgrade to make the buyer surprised and more happy:)

 

thanks once again!