if you had the choice of 2 NM issues

[anstettoman]

and one was a misprint cover is on upside down (meaning you have to flip the book over and open back cover to read it) and a non misprint issue of the same grade, which one would you pick for your collection?

[seanfingh]

 

This is one of the weirdest questions ever. I would choose Action 1.

[marvelcollector]

Action 1...and Action 1

[thunsicker]

I'd choose the original art from Action #1.

 

[HarveySwick]

Tec 27 and AF 15

[slym2none]

I think he wants us to choose either the misprint or the regular version. Not which issue of either.

 

IDK anyone would choose the misprint, but then again, I am not everyone.

 

 

 

 

-slym

[toro]

Action 1 and 1 noitcA

[Artboy99]

and one was a misprint cover is on upside down (meaning you have to flip the book over and open back cover to read it) and a non misprint issue of the same grade, which one would you pick for your collection?

 

Depends entirely on the book to me. Some title I am actively collecting I might want the manufacturing defect copy.

Something unimportant I wouldn't care.

[HarveySwick]

I think he wants us to choose either the misprint or the regular version. Not which issue of either.

 

IDK anyone would choose the misprint, but then again, I am not everyone.

 

 

-slym

 

I didn't read the fine print. Only the subject line.

[kav]

My Action #1 was printed that way-I merely pulled the staples and fixed it.

[thunsicker]

I think he wants us to choose either the misprint or the regular version. Not which issue of either.

 

IDK anyone would choose the misprint, but then again, I am not everyone.

 

 

 

 

-slym

 

Oh, sorry I misunderstood. Then the original art to Action #1 upside down.

[miraclemet]

Misprints never held any interest for me, so I'd take the "correct" one.

 

On a side note would CGC slab it with the cover right side up, or upside down?

[Ryan.]

Tec 27 and AF 15 TMNT 1

 

[joe_collector]

Action 1 definitely. No question.

[Ken Aldred]

Rather than the first full appearances of Cable and Deadpool in NM 87 and 98, not being much of a fan of the series, I'd probably leave it entirely and settle for a near perfect, non-misprint Action 1 and Tec 27.

[Cyclops]

What issue is it?

[thunsicker]

What issue is it?

 

Hypothetical Comics #1

[Ken Aldred]

What about if you had a Valiant flip book with one cover printed with the wrong orientation?

[Griff]

Depends entirely on the book

[Artboy99]

As I mentioned above, it depends entirely on the book. If it is a run of the mill comic I don't care much for I would take the regular copy.

If it is a title I am collecting, I might want the error book and possibly a regular copy as well.

 

here is an example of an error book in a title I am collecting:

 

 

In this case I absolutely choose the error book. it is in great condition, is a golden age book, and it is argueably my favorite Planet Comics I own because of it's uniqueness. It is very likely the only copy in existence that is both a double cover and off-register printing.