HERO FOR HIRE #2 NICE COPY?

[WHIZ_BANG_POW]

BOOK has white to off white pages, inside clean and complete. Firmly attached at cover and through book, by both staples. I want to say its a 7.0 but im hard on silver age books and its hard for me to grade them because I have seen slabs that are 9.0 that look as good as this one. any opinions would help. there is no blunt corners or creasing on the book. Lays flat also.

 

[ROBTOTHEC]

First of all scanning a White comic with a white background is

against the rules in this Forum!

It makes us all crazy and want to scream.

So, let's re-scan so we can help you out properly.

Thanks!

[WHIZ_BANG_POW]

First of all scanning a White comic with a white background is

against the rules in this Forum!

It makes us all crazy and want to scream.

So, let's re-scan so we can help you out properly.

Thanks!

 

Is this better? sorry was not thinking

[timfinz]

Do you have links to larger scans? It's always harder to try and guess what's going on with a book when the scans are smaller than the book!

[WHIZ_BANG_POW]

does these work?

[kav]

8.0

[WHIZ_BANG_POW]

8.0

thanks for the input. I thought it was pretty nice. Needed some other opinions

[timfinz]

8.5 IMHO! Your mis-wrapped cover doesn't effect the grade just the aesthetics!

[paul747]

Is that foxing on the lower front left corner ? 7.5

[WHIZ_BANG_POW]

Is that foxing on the lower front left corner ? 7.5

 

yes there is a little foxing

[timfinz]

Is that foxing on the lower front left corner ? 7.5

 

yes there is a little foxing

Should never review these books on a computer screen in a sunlit room. All I see is my shadow but I didn't see the foxing!

That'll drop your grade but I'm only going to 8.0!

[WHIZ_BANG_POW]

no

Is that foxing on the lower front left corner ? 7.5

 

yes there is a little foxing

Should never review these books on a computer screen in a sunlit room. All I see is my shadow but I didn't see the foxing!

That'll drop your grade but I'm only going to 8.0!

now that will drop the grade, but what about a dark cover where you cant see the foxing?

[timfinz]

Is that foxing on the lower front left corner ? 7.5

Good eye Paul!

[timfinz]

no

Is that foxing on the lower front left corner ? 7.5

 

yes there is a little foxing

Should never review these books on a computer screen in a sunlit room. All I see is my shadow but I didn't see the foxing!

That'll drop your grade but I'm only going to 8.0!

now that will drop the grade, but what about a dark cover where you cant see the foxing?

Oh we'll eventually sniff it out!

[kav]

the foxing is why i said 8.0 vs 8.5

[WHIZ_BANG_POW]

that means you have eagle eyes (thumbs u

[kav]

not so eagle eyed in the strange tales comp.....

[WHIZ_BANG_POW]

not so eagle eyed in the strange tales comp.....

oh.........should I even ask??

[ROBTOTHEC]

I'm having a hard time getting above a 7.0