Is this the most overgraded cgc 9.4 ever?

[drdonaldblake]

http://www.pedigreecomics.com/auction-detail.php?issue_id=47250

 

how on earth did this get a 9.4?

[Wally's Comics]

"Shaken Not Stirred"

 

 

[drdonaldblake]

?

[THE_BEYONDER]

I don't know, but are his scans always that blurry? Or is that intentional?

[Boboset]

That's gross. I've never seen a worse 9.4.

 

 

[THE_BEYONDER]

"Shaken Not Stirred"

 

 

 

Not easy to shake those spine breaks into existence

[kav]

It's not horrible but way too many spine stress marks for that grade.

I say 8.5

[Boboset]

"Shaken Not Stirred"

 

 

 

Not easy to shake those spine breaks into existence

Yup.

[Boboset]

It's not horrible but way too many spine stress marks for that grade.

I say 8.5

Having an 8.5 sitting in a 9.4 case is pretty horrible IMO.

[rodan57]

 

" This is a perfectly structured and newsstand clean and fresh Near-Mint book, with insane MILK white pages, a gorgeous spine, sharp edges, pointy corners and exceptional eye appeal and color strike. "

[THE_BEYONDER]

Insane MILK white pages....

[Boboset]

I'm surprised Pedigree would accept that book.

[kav]

 

" This is a perfectly structured and newsstand clean and fresh Near-Mint book, with insane MILK white pages, a gorgeous spine, sharp edges, pointy corners and exceptional eye appeal and color strike. "

GORGEOUS SPINE?? WTF?

Pointy heads maybe-THE GRADERS.......

[Conan_Aficionado]

weak 9.4, without a doubt, but at the right price, that's a beautiful 9.4

[Griff]

more like a 8.0 that got blessed by a grader who happened to be distracted by 2 chipmunks tap dancing in a tree

[Conan_Aficionado]

more like a 8.0 that got blessed by a grader who happened to be distracted by 2 chipmunks tap dancing in a tree

 

when did they switch to a one grader system.

[kav]

more like a 8.0 that got blessed by a grader who happened to be distracted by 2 chipmunks tap dancing in a tree

 

when did they switch to a one grader system.

3 graders six chipmunks?

[Conan_Aficionado]

more like a 8.0 that got blessed by a grader who happened to be distracted by 2 chipmunks tap dancing in a tree

 

when did they switch to a one grader system.

 

more like three blind mice and a one eyed oger

[Wally's Comics]

It's not horrible but way too many spine stress marks for that grade.

I say 8.5

Having an 8.5 sitting in a 9.4 case is pretty horrible IMO.

 

I think the mysteries of a dark cover strike again!

[Conan_Aficionado]

what if some defects were introduced after the grading phase.