• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

CGC Green Eggs Grading Contest Round 4

Started by thirdgreenham,

118 posts in this topic

oakman29

oakman29

Posted
Posted
Wow, that was a sick grade they gave that MIS, did anyone get that one???

 

Not me. I gave it a 7.0 :(

 

All this just wouldn't let me grade it 8.0 VF

 

bc corner.... piece missing

 

MysteryInSpace_BCcorner2_zps7458660c.jpg

 

bc .....other corner.... numerous pages ripped

 

MysteryInSpace_BCcorner_zps3a424dc6.jpg

 

bc ....side ....rip, missing even ?

 

MysteryInSpace_BCside_zps62a4a454.jpg

 

 

bc ....top..... ripped....crunched .....pressed hm:grin:

 

MysteryInSpace_BCtop_zpseb619850.jpg

 

 

fc..... corner....torn pages show from the back cover trouble

 

MysteryInSpace_FCcorner_zps6525e6f1.jpg

 

and last.....fc top corner.... looked like another small piece missing, but maybe its the artwork......then theres that color breaking scrape through the DC logo :(

 

MysteryInSpace_FCcornertop_zps0751fcbc.jpg

 

Thank you Mike,at least I don't feel crazy.Like I'm missing something here.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Park

Park

Posted
Posted

I look at it that it is incredibly hard to grade from a scan and that I don't know how to grade all that well.

 

:ohnoez:

Link to comment
Share on other sites
thirdgreenham

thirdgreenham

Posted
  • Author
Posted
Wow, that was a sick grade they gave that MIS, did anyone get that one???

 

Not me. I gave it a 7.0 :(

 

All this just wouldn't let me grade it 8.0 VF

 

bc corner.... piece missing

 

MysteryInSpace_BCcorner2_zps7458660c.jpg

 

bc .....other corner.... numerous pages ripped

 

MysteryInSpace_BCcorner_zps3a424dc6.jpg

 

bc ....side ....rip, missing even ?

 

MysteryInSpace_BCside_zps62a4a454.jpg

 

 

bc ....top..... ripped....crunched .....pressed hm:grin:

 

MysteryInSpace_BCtop_zpseb619850.jpg

 

 

fc..... corner....torn pages show from the back cover trouble

 

MysteryInSpace_FCcorner_zps6525e6f1.jpg

 

and last.....fc top corner.... looked like another small piece missing, but maybe its the artwork......then theres that color breaking scrape through the DC logo :(

 

MysteryInSpace_FCcornertop_zps0751fcbc.jpg

 

Jeez, when you put it that way, my book looks like :censored:

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Park

Park

Posted
Posted
Wow, that was a sick grade they gave that MIS, did anyone get that one???
I went 7.0 wanted to edit my grade to 7.5. Never thought an 8.0 was possible there. What did you grade it as?

 

 

I would really like to have seen that book in hand to grade it. Looked like a tough book that presented great from front with BC issues. I had it at 7.5 because of the tanning/damage combo I thought it would just get knocked off of 8.0

Agree with the 7.5 ceiling... You'd have to have balls of steel to sell that as a raw 8.0.

 

The one thing I'll say kind of in CGC's defense is that I can imagine this cover's black inks really "pop" in hand more than in the scans. Just a hunch, but they do look a bit more vibrant in Andy's reveal photo.

 

 

:blush:

 

How did you get a hold of my reveal photo???

 

You PM it to anyone that even glances your way.

 

PM sent, big boy. :wink:

 

You have been working out. :whee:

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Senormac

Senormac

Posted
Posted
To get the 8.0 I'm thinking some/most of the bottom spine corner was ruled production related. Sound about right?

 

Looks mouse related.

 

lol

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Boboset

Boboset

Posted
Posted
To get the 8.0 I'm thinking some/most of the bottom spine corner was ruled production related. Sound about right?

 

Looks mouse related.

lol Well so much for that idea!
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Park

Park

Posted
Posted
Wow, that was a sick grade they gave that MIS, did anyone get that one???

 

Not me. I gave it a 7.0 :(

 

All this just wouldn't let me grade it 8.0 VF

 

bc corner.... piece missing

 

MysteryInSpace_BCcorner2_zps7458660c.jpg

 

bc .....other corner.... numerous pages ripped

 

MysteryInSpace_BCcorner_zps3a424dc6.jpg

 

bc ....side ....rip, missing even ?

 

MysteryInSpace_BCside_zps62a4a454.jpg

 

 

bc ....top..... ripped....crunched .....pressed hm:grin:

 

MysteryInSpace_BCtop_zpseb619850.jpg

 

 

fc..... corner....torn pages show from the back cover trouble

 

MysteryInSpace_FCcorner_zps6525e6f1.jpg

 

and last.....fc top corner.... looked like another small piece missing, but maybe its the artwork......then theres that color breaking scrape through the DC logo :(

 

MysteryInSpace_FCcornertop_zps0751fcbc.jpg

 

Jeez, when you put it that way, my book looks like :censored:

 

lol

Link to comment
Share on other sites
SNiPER

SNiPER

Posted
Posted
Mystery In Space #5 CGC 8.0

 

a028_zps0972f62d.jpg

 

 

This is funny, Andy PM'd me after I sent in my grade to tell me that he thought

I might have sold him the book!

I went back in my sales records and turns out I sold it to him raw here on the boards a while back, I had graded it at a 7.0! :cry:

 

And this time I graded it at 7.0 again :cry::cry:

 

At least my under grading was consistent :sumo:

 

Nice to see it got a 8.0 Andy! (thumbs u

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Senormac

Senormac

Posted
Posted
Mystery In Space #5 CGC 8.0

 

a028_zps0972f62d.jpg

 

 

This is funny, Andy PM'd me after I sent in my grade to tell me that he thought

I might have sold him the book!

I went back in my sales records and turns out I sold it to him raw here on the boards a while back, I had graded it at a 7.0! :cry:

 

And this time I graded it at 7.0 again :cry::cry:

 

At least my under grading was consistent :sumo:

 

 

(thumbs u

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Boboset

Boboset

Posted
Posted
Mystery In Space #5 CGC 8.0

 

a028_zps0972f62d.jpg

 

 

This is funny, Andy PM'd me after I sent in my grade to tell me that he thought

I might have sold him the book!

I went back in my sales records and turns out I sold it to him raw here on the boards a while back, I had graded it at a 7.0! :cry:

 

And this time I graded it at 7.0 again :cry::cry:

 

At least my under grading was consistent :sumo:

 

Nice to see it got a 8.0 Andy! (thumbs u

That is really funny!
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Go to topic listing