Please grade my Sub-Mariner #8 - The Thing!

[divad]

 

 

 

[DiceX]

7.5/8.0

Nice looking copy of the only issue of "Fairy Pants" I would consider owning.

[supapimp]

FN+ 6.5

[DiceX]

Is that a long scratch across the book at the bottom?

If so, I'll say 7.0.

[supapimp]

it's not the scratch that made me grade it a 6.5, it's the ULC crunch in the subby box. but it is a borderline 6.5-7.0.

[uclapeterg]

7.0.

[ninanina]

Can't add anything new. All the classic signs of a 7.5.

[divad]

FN+ 6.5

 

As low bidder, Supe - you're on! I personally guarantee that this book will be graded 8.0 AT A MINIMUM by CGC.

 

I win - you pay the grading fee.

 

You win - I pay you the grading fee.

 

Whaddya say? ( meow )

[divad]

Is that a long scratch across the book at the bottom?

If so, I'll say 7.0.

 

It's really weird - there's nothing on the book - I'm wondering if I had the scan cover closed all the way . . .

[divad]

it's not the scratch that made me grade it a 6.5, it's the ULC crunch in the subby box. but it is a borderline 6.5-7.0.

 

Note btw how that ULC "crunch" doesn't translate to the back cover . . .

 

borderline my batooski!

[supapimp]

OK, submit it at the WC next year for on-site grading.

[arexcrooke]

btw 7.5

[FFB]

FN+ 6.5

 

As low bidder, Supe - you're on! I personally guarantee that this book will be graded 8.0 AT A MINIMUM by CGC.

 

I win - you pay the grading fee.

 

You win - I pay you the grading fee.

 

Whaddya say? ( meow )

 

I think I graded this one 7.5 to 8.0 at your house, didn't I?

[divad]

OK, submit it at the WC next year for on-site grading.

 

It's going in the mail tomorrow, along with three others. You do plan on being around in three months - don't you?

[divad]

FN+ 6.5

 

As low bidder, Supe - you're on! I personally guarantee that this book will be graded 8.0 AT A MINIMUM by CGC.

 

I win - you pay the grading fee.

 

You win - I pay you the grading fee.

 

Whaddya say? ( meow )

 

I think I graded this one 7.5 to 8.0 at your house, didn't I?

I can't recall precisely (due to the flurry of books) but yes, this is the one I showed you guys Saturday - the scan doesn't do it justice.

[Stronguy]

I'd say FN/VF mabye even VF-.

[nik]

7.5 tops

[supapimp]

i'll be at the WC in february aren't you? so the bet is if it doesn't get at least a 8.0 you lose right?. if so we then have an accord.

[divad]

i'll be at the WC in february aren't you? so the bet is if it doesn't get at least a 8.0 you lose right?. if so we then have an accord.

 

I will be at the dinner but conventions are not my gig. Yes, that is the bet.

[jimm94]

You guys should up the ante and send it via Walkthru service. If Divad's right, Supa pays. If Supa is right, Divad pays AND Supa gets to keep the book!