Please grade my action comics 38

[Ares]

Just arrived today

Inside is freaking incredible. Bight and no colour warps and practically white pages!

Only cover is any problem area

[143ksk]

Very nice

 

Is there a spine split at the bottom? I assume that the issue at the top of the spine is a scuff.

 

I would say it's somewhere in the high VG range--VG/FN if there's no spine split.

 

Congrats!

[Ares]

Scuff at top

small split at bottom

[143ksk]

VG+ (4.5 for the letter impaired) then--still a great book!

[rjpb]

It looks like a FN to me.

[divad]

I'll split the difference at VG/FN 5.0 due to the 1" spine split at bottom and slight erasure at top. btw, I love great PQ!

[Ares]

I had to downgrade the image quality in order to make image fit the filze size but had amazing cover gloss

[divad]

I had to downgrade the image quality in order to make image fit the filze size but had amazing cover gloss

 

Ok, Ok - 6.0

 

[nik]

Very nice copy, hate to be sour on my guess on the grade but I would grade it at 4.0, 4.5 tops

[burntboy]

this book presents beautifully.........

 

i think the spine split will bring it down into the 5.0 - 5.5 range. the colors are quite amazing and it is GA, after all...............

[Mephisto]

5.0 is definitely attainable even with the spine split. My Tec 40 had a spine split that was in the middle of the spine.

[PovertyRow]

VG+ (4.5 for the letter impaired) then--still a great book!

 

 

Bring back the Alpha Grade!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[PovertyRow]

Man that is a tough call. I could see it doing a 5.0 anyway. Yes, there are some problem areas but from the scan some decided LACK of problems in the cover. In any case, it is a very nice book and one to enjoy!

[PovertyRow]

5.0 is definitely attainable even with the spine split. My Tec 40 had a spine split that was in the middle of the spine.

 

My 5.5/Fine- has a inch or so spine split and also a 90 degree split (it is shaped like the letter "L") partway down the back cover.

[Ares]

Just got it back today and it was a 5.5

[arexcrooke]

Just got it back today and it was a 5.5

[uclapeterg]

Just got it back today and it was a 5.5

 

I think it "presents" better than a 5.5.

[Aces]

Just got it back today and it was a 5.5

 

This was posted durning my PC down time Dec/Jan...

 

I would have guess 5.0.

 

Congrats on the grade!

[143ksk]

Congrats on the nice grade