Ever Resub a book for Sig series and it goes up a grade?

[Ares]

I submitted a Green Lantern 89 to get a Neal Adams and Denny ONeil sigs.

Originally it was a 9.6 and playing around with the Certification Lookup I was able to find out the book went up to a 9.8.

 

Maybe they grade to harshly last time. Either way

 

Has this happened to anyone before ?

[mysterio]

Several times. I've gotten more upgrades than downgrades.

[kaholo1256]

Same here, but usually if it isn't a 9.8 I almost always press it now.

[RockMyAmadeus]

I submitted a Green Lantern 89 to get a Neal Adams and Denny ONeil sigs.

Originally it was a 9.6 and playing around with the Certification Lookup I was able to find out the book went up to a 9.8.

 

Maybe they grade to harshly last time. Either way

 

Has this happened to anyone before ?

yes

[NYComics]

Yes LOTS of times this has happened

[Ares]

I was surprised when i saw it..

I wonder what they missed/saw first time around

[Ryan.]

I had an originally blue label 7.0 Bone 1 cracked and signed in Boston and it's coming back an 8.0. I'm actually not that surprised, as when I gave the book a thorough inspection I thought there was no way it was a 7.0. Not sure what happened with that original grading but it was a clear miss.

[kaholo1256]

Personally I chalk it up as human error. If it were machine checked maybe I would be more surprised but with so little difference between things like 9.6 and 9.8 and graders not knowing the original grade it's bound to happen and often.

[mysterio]

Personally I chalk it up as human error. If it were machine checked maybe I would be more surprised but with so little difference between things like 9.6 and 9.8 and graders not knowing the original grade it's bound to happen and often.

 

 

There are a lot of 9.6s in 9.8 slabs and vice versa. At that level it is sometimes luck of the draw, or whether or not the grader had a nice breakfast that morning.

[Ares]

I figured since it was a pedigreed book they would have a know what it was before.

As I said its a win for me.

[Dark Prime 0]

my ghostbusters book went from a 9.6 to 9.8 after another sig was put on it