Guess The Grades with a Twist

[nik]

I will post 3 different books which were purchased from three different venues. One was from Ebay which was advertised as a NM. One was from my LCS which we thought was a VF. And the last one from Heritage which was advertised as a NM-. I didnt include back cover scans, because IMO there was really nothing that would stick out to sway your guess. I will post the grades early next week.

 

If by some crazy wild chance anyone guesses the correct grades and from whom the books were bought I will send him a Modern CGC book as a prize.

 

Here we go

[october]

I'll take a shot...

 

Avengers 27 9.6 heritage

 

X-Men 40 8.5 LCS

 

ASM 122 9.2 ebay

[nik]

I'll take a shot...

 

Avengers 57 9.6 heritage

 

Its 27

[divad]

Nice books there Niko - Love those covers!

[DiceX]

9.6

9.2

8.5

[october]

I'll take a shot...

 

Avengers 57 9.6 heritage

 

Its 27

 

Whoops!

[joeno3]

Hi Nikos were these graded when purchased or did you have them slabbed?

[Jeffreykli]

Avengers 27 - eBay - 9.4

X-Men 40 - Heritage - 9.0

Spidey 122 - LCS - 7.0

[divad]

9.4 Heritage

8.5 LCS

9.0 ebay

 

[Mithril Man]

Avengers Heritage 9.4

Spider-Man Ebay 9.2

X-Men LCS 7.5

[inconceivable]

Avengers 27 NM 9.4 (ebay)

X-Men 40 VF/NM 9.0 (LCS)

ASM 122 VF/NM 9.0 (Heritage)

 

I was close to saying all grades were as advertised but the XMen looks nicer and the ASM has that little crease. Nice books and I hope you are pleased with the results.

 

Dan

[Tango 'n Cash]

Avengers 27 - Heritage - 9.4

X-Men 40 - LCS - 9.0

Spidey 122 - EBay - 9.0

[nik]

No they were all bought raw, and I sent them in to CGC.

[Comicdey]

My guess and hoping that you got a great deal on EBAY for the Avengers. I also picked the high side of my guess range for all copies while looking at the glass half full.

 

Avengers 9.4 Ebay

X-Men 40 8.0 LCS

SM 122 8.5 Heritage

[namisgr]

Let me try a divergent guess:

 

Avengers - 9.4 from E-Bay (!)

 

X-Men 8.5 from LCS

 

ASM 9.0 from Heritage

[Comicdey]

You must have just read my post and be an optimist. We'll See

[awe4one]

Avengers - 9.4 Dealer

 

X-Men - 8.5 EBay

 

ASM - 9.0 Heritage

[joeno3]

 

Avengers #27 9.2 Ebay

 

x-men 8.0 LCS

 

Asm #122 8.5 heritage

[rjpb]

Avengers 27 - 9.6 - ebay

 

X-men 40 - 9.0 - LCS

 

ASM 122 - 9.2 - Heritage

[Mr. Zipper]

I will post 3 different books which were purchased from three different venues. One was from Ebay which was advertised as a NM. One was from my LCS which we thought was a VF. And the last one from Heritage which was advertised as a NM-. I didnt include back cover scans, because IMO there was really nothing that would stick out to sway your guess. I will post the grades early next week.

 

If by some crazy wild chance anyone guesses the correct grades and from whom the books were bought I will send him a Modern CGC book as a prize.

 

 

Avengers 27 was the Heritage NM- / CGC grade = 9.6

X Men 40 was LCS VF / CGC grade = 9.0

ASM 122 was eBay NM / CGC grade = 8.5