PGM Star Wars #1 (1977) Copy E (higher grade)

[Calidream'n]

So, this is one of 2 copies I have that I feel might hit 9.6/9.8. Let me know what you guys think. Aside from the tiny, less than a half a millimeter crease on the top R corner (which may be a print defect? I can't feel any "crease"), aside from that, I see no spine ticks, colors is sharp and gloss is great. Corners pretty sharp and no back or front cover dents. To look at it from an angle in the light the covers are completely smooth. ow/white pages. I know there is a very slight miswrap, but I don't know if that would effect grade.

 

[2AGuy]

For me, I think I'd be at 9.4/9.6 as-is due to color breaks on FCUR (including right edge), soft FCLL and FCLR corners, and dirty/ink rub on back cover. I'm leaning more 9.4 than 9.6. See what others say, though, as I am fairly new here. Nice copy, but I do "feel your pain"

[Calidream'n]

For me, I think I'd be at 9.4/9.6 as-is due to color breaks on FCUR (including right edge), soft FCLL and FCLR corners, and dirty/ink rub on back cover. I'm leaning more 9.4 than 9.6. See what others say, though, as I am fairly new here. Nice copy, but I do "feel your pain"

Thanks for the input. I don't know if it's the scan or the bad interior page cut that leave a bit of an overhang and makes the corners harder to see, but they are all pretty sharp in hand. I wonder if cleaning up the b/c would help the grade?

[Calidream'n]

anyone else?

[timfinz]

9.6 IMHO!

[oakman29]

9.4

[mdean2437]

9.4