Spidey #51 - Opinions, please.

[Jeffreykli]

Let me know what you would grade this...biggest defects are the crease through the logo and the missing LRC:

 

 

[Aces]

Without those two problems I'd say you'd have a 8.5 there.

With them: 7.0

[supapimp]

4.5/5.0 due to missing LRC

[Aces]

4.5/5.0 due to missing LRC

 

That's a major grade drop for a small chip!

 

Anyone got that scan of the 8.5 TOS 40 with the major marvel chipping.

 

I took off one point for the chip and a half point for the crease.

[uclapeterg]

I was thinking 5.0 too. Chipping is a production defect, but this is a situation of LRC entirely missing.

[supapimp]

it might recieve a "Q" grade.

[FFB]

I was thinking 5.0 too. Chipping is a production defect, but this is a situation of LRC entirely missing.

 

Right. Steve B. said once that they are not as hard on Marvel chipping as they are on stuff like this.

[CW]

6.5, it has good eye appeal. Nice book

[verygoodplus]

This is a toughie...

 

I'll say 5.5.

[uclapeterg]

I was thinking 5.0 too. Chipping is a production defect, but this is a situation of LRC entirely missing.

 

Right. Steve B. said once that they are not as hard on Marvel chipping as they are on stuff like this.

 

I'm right about something! Yea for me!

[toro]

Tough call there, with all the other flaws, stress, scratch etc. and then the corner, range of 4.5 to 5.5

[Ajax]

5.0/5.5

[Jeffreykli]

Thanks for all the input. I was curious how much of a downgrade the missing piece would be.