X-men #34 is it really a 9.2?

[Enrico R.]

Hi everyone,

I bought a X-men 34 CGC graded 9.2.

It's a really beautiful book, but there are many stress marks on the spine with color break, so I was asking myself if it can truly be considered a 9.2.

I would grade it closer to a 9.0, but I would like to hear your opinion since I'm not even close to being an expert.

 

Thank you.

Enrico

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[HighStakesComics]

It looks awfully nice to me.

[Enrico R.]

It looks awfully nice to me.

 

Yes, it's beautiful, but isn't that spine bringing down the grade? I mean, is it still acceptable for a 9.2?

[Mijael.Levy]

It looks awfully nice to me.

 

Yes, it's beautiful, but isn't that spine bringing down the grade? I mean, is it still acceptable for a 9.2?

 

No its not a 9.2 a 9.0 probably

[Enrico R.]

It looks awfully nice to me.

 

Yes, it's beautiful, but isn't that spine bringing down the grade? I mean, is it still acceptable for a 9.2?

 

No its not a 9.2 100%

 

So, CGC isn't always right

[Mijael.Levy]

Not every time but they are the best graders

[Enrico R.]

Not every time but they are the best graders

That's for sure.

Do you think my X-men is closer to a 9.0 or to a 8.5?

[thecopperagekids]

Not every time but they are the best graders

That's for sure.

Do you think my X-men is closer to a 9.0 or to a 8.5?

 

If I were to buy that book in a CGC 9.2 holder, I would not have any issue with the assigned grade.

[Mijael.Levy]

Not every time but they are the best graders

That's for sure.

Do you think my X-men is closer to a 9.0 or to a 8.5?

 

To a 9.0 IMO

[vaillant]

I would probably accept it as a VFNM but as said it looks a bit flawed for a NM-

 

Well, I have a deslabbed Dr. Strange that was a 9.4 and surely looks a bit less, so it might happen… No one is purr-fect!

[Gotham Kid]

9.0