PGM: Fantastic Four # 17

[Steviehuv66]

Purchased from Metropolis Comics. Thank you in advance for your grading comments!

 

 

[grebal]

Structurally looks at least F, which is what I think CGC rates it on [so 6 or 6.5], but I tend to grade a comic as capped by it's overall eye appeal (i.e. max grade I can give it). Which is why if selling I might grade it vg/f. At the top end some sellers might grade it 7.0 ?

[Primetime]

Steve, is that a small corner out lower BC and crease upper spine on BC?

 

I'd say 5.0

[makeminemego]

I'd say around 5.0 is a good guess.

 

Even better, what did Metro call the book? I've always found their mid-grades......interesting.

[Steviehuv66]

Good call Ben on the lower bc piece missing. As a matter of fact, that piece is in the mylar, so I just left it there. I will check the book for a crease. Metro graded the book a 6.8, F ++. It was part of their Might Marvel Maniac Collection.

[jdw1991]

5.0-5.5

[Ron Rau]

5.0-5.5

 

Me too.

[Michelangelo]

it is a little dark/dirty, which hurts the eye appeal.

 

but the reason I think this is higher than the above mentioned: no long colour breaking creases and the edges are relatively sharp.

 

my guess is 6.0 - even with the tiny BC piece out, that's still permissible in F grades.