PGM Aquaman 11 - Tough One #1

[1Cool]

Missing that chip out of the bottom corner but has nice crisp pages and great gloss.

 

[1Cool]

No rust on staples so the small rust stains on back must have come from another book.

[1Cool]

30 views and no one want to break the ice?

[comicjack]

At least a 5.0 maybe 5.5 on a good day

[drotto]

I was going to go with a 6.0. This is historically a person_without_enough_empathy of a book in high grade.

[Bomber-Bob]

That's a pretty long crease on the bottom right, actually multiple creases. There's a vertical reader's crease, an upper right crease, the chip, the rust stains..... I'm thinking 5.0 . Sorry.

[Ron C.]

Black covers are tough. Even with the back corner 5.5-6.0.

[HighStakesComics]

4.5

[Point Five]

4.5; nice one for the grade tho!

 

 

[1Cool]

That's a pretty long crease on the bottom right, actually multiple creases. There's a vertical reader's crease, an upper right crease, the chip, the rust stains..... I'm thinking 5.0 . Sorry.

 

Definitely don't be sorry. Grabbed it for $22 last week at a Con. Was thinking 5.0 myself but I'm not too familiar with chunks out of the back cover. Thanks for the grades guys.

[comicjack]

You got a good deal

[fiendish]

4.5-5.0

[drotto]

That's a pretty long crease on the bottom right, actually multiple creases. There's a vertical reader's crease, an upper right crease, the chip, the rust stains..... I'm thinking 5.0 . Sorry.

 

Definitely don't be sorry. Grabbed it for $22 last week at a Con. Was thinking 5.0 myself but I'm not too familiar with chunks out of the back cover. Thanks for the grades guys.

 

One hell of a deal for that price. I have seen lower grades go for $100 easy.

[Mr Sneeze]

That's a nice book! VG/F all the way for me, though no shame in VG or VG+

[electricprune]

That's a pretty long crease on the bottom right, actually multiple creases. There's a vertical reader's crease, an upper right crease, the chip, the rust stains..... I'm thinking 5.0 . Sorry.

 

Definitely don't be sorry. Grabbed it for $22 last week at a Con. Was thinking 5.0 myself but I'm not too familiar with chunks out of the back cover. Thanks for the grades guys.

 

Andrew, I just sold a CGC 4.0 OW/W for over $200 on ebay. You did well on this one. I'd be happy to give you $66 for it right now to triple your money!

[DR.X]

4.5; nice one for the grade tho!

 

 

I agree. Just too many defects here to go higher for me. the long diagonal crease on the lower corner, he crease along the spine and the piece out of the back cover corner are the big ones. I see multiple tears on the bottom edge B.C. too.

 

The book is still a nice looking copy though and has good color to it. I think that back cover would clean up pretty good and it would look great in a mylite.

[1Cool]

Thanks guys - think I'm going to give it a press and clean and sub it. Fingers crossed for a 5.5 after a clean.

[1Cool]

That's a pretty long crease on the bottom right, actually multiple creases. There's a vertical reader's crease, an upper right crease, the chip, the rust stains..... I'm thinking 5.0 . Sorry.

 

Definitely don't be sorry. Grabbed it for $22 last week at a Con. Was thinking 5.0 myself but I'm not too familiar with chunks out of the back cover. Thanks for the grades guys.

 

Andrew, I just sold a CGC 4.0 OW/W for over $200 on ebay. You did well on this one. I'd be happy to give you $66 for it right now to triple your money!

 

You sir are too kind!

[electricprune]

That's a pretty long crease on the bottom right, actually multiple creases. There's a vertical reader's crease, an upper right crease, the chip, the rust stains..... I'm thinking 5.0 . Sorry.

 

Definitely don't be sorry. Grabbed it for $22 last week at a Con. Was thinking 5.0 myself but I'm not too familiar with chunks out of the back cover. Thanks for the grades guys.

 

Andrew, I just sold a CGC 4.0 OW/W for over $200 on ebay. You did well on this one. I'd be happy to give you $66 for it right now to triple your money!

 

You sir are too kind!

 

You're always great to buy from so it's the least I can do!