Green Lantern #59 - What Do You Think?

[awe4one]

I haven't posted any of these in awhile so I'm going to post a couple to keep me honest...

 

Green Lantern #59 - Some slight wear on spine and top edge. Nothing of note on back...

 

 

Jim

[Aces]

7.5

 

I'm not sure if there is too much spine wear for a full VF or not.

But it's close.

[bullseye]

B+ Ha! but 8.0 seems right.

[FFB]

7.5

 

I'm not sure if there is too much spine wear for a full VF or not.

But it's close.

 

I agree.

[uclapeterg]

7.5

 

I'm not sure if there is too much spine wear for a full VF or not.

But it's close.

 

I agree.

 

I agree with FFB and A (for once)

[herc2000]

looks like a colour touch, bottom left?

[awe4one]

I agree as well...in fact you may have been generous...

 

Bought as a "HIGH GRADE" VF/NM from a Forum member awhile back. Never really took a good look at it before this morning...

 

Jim

[nik]

I agree as well...in fact you may have been generous...

 

Bought as a "HIGH GRADE" VF/NM from a Forum member awhile back. Never really took a good look at it before this morning...

 

Jim

 

[Aces]

7.5

 

I'm not sure if there is too much spine wear for a full VF or not.

But it's close.

 

I agree.

 

I agree with FFB and A (for once)

 

[uclapeterg]

Which forum member? Do tell!

[divad]

I agree as well...in fact you may have been generous...

 

Bought as a "HIGH GRADE" VF/NM from a Forum member awhile back. Never really took a good look at it before this morning...

 

Jim

 

And that would be . . . ?

[awe4one]

I agree as well...in fact you may have been generous...

 

Bought as a "HIGH GRADE" VF/NM from a Forum member awhile back. Never really took a good look at it before this morning...

 

Jim

 

And that would be . . . ?

 

A Forum member. Not sure calling him out a year after buying the comic is appropriate because I didn't check it close enough when it arrived...

 

Jim

[burntboy]

I agree as well...in fact you may have been generous...

 

Bought as a "HIGH GRADE" VF/NM from a Forum member awhile back. Never really took a good look at it before this morning...

 

Jim

 

And that would be . . . ?

 

A Forum member. Not sure calling him out a year after buying the comic is appropriate because I didn't check it close enough when it arrived...

 

Jim

 

good point, and i think the right choice..........a very nice looking book which upon closer scrutiny, isn't quite what it was touted as.

 

i might contact them anyway and ask what they think of it now, based on their further learning experience from these boards.

 

but, a year later seems too long to complain about the grade. now, if said book were found to be restored, i'd definitely contact him about it.................