Please advise on Hulk #2

[Nefaria]

Three questions;

1. What Grade do you feel this comic is?

2. Would you CGC it?

3. If you would CGC it would it pass for Economy Grading Fee or would the value require a Standard Grading Fee?

Thanks

[Nefaria]

Front Cover

[bullseye]

ima guess 4.0/4.5, not sure what exactly the OS is in that range for that particular book though.

 

comicpriceguide puts it at 675/765 for that grade range, though i am not sure what gpa has it at.

[Flaming_Telepath]

G/VG

No

Economy

[Arty]

Good 2.0

 

G+ at best.

[Aces]

2.0 But a solid 2.0!

Wish it was mine.

 

ECO

 

My new 2005 OS that I got yesterday says $229 for a Good.

[mrwoogieman]

3.0

 

I've reconsidered on the grade, downward

 

2.5

 

 

[divad]

You guys are high . . . trust me on this one:

 

1.8 In the same league as my AF #15 and Spidey #1

 

(with obvious apologies to Arte and Aces)

[143ksk]

Good 2.0

 

G+ at best.

 

[burntboy]

my initial reaction was a 3.0, but after looking more closely, there's a lot of stuff going on here. i think it still might pull a 2.0 - 2.5, though.

 

i'm gonna post mine as well and get some input. for some reason, my Hulk 1-6 fared the worst of all my 12cent comics...........(oh, and annuals, too..............)

[Silver Surfer]

4.0

[fable]

2.0

[burntboy]

4.0

 

i'm quite pleased to see this grading opinion - take a peek at mine when you have a moment.................

[divad]

4.0

 

i'm quite pleased to see this grading opinion - take a peek at mine when you have a moment.................

 

This copy is BEAT (no offense) -- compare to BB's . . .

[divad]

4.0

SOLD!

[Silver Surfer]

Okay I didn't take a very good look at it but I still think it can get a 3.0. Overall it looks much better than most 2.0's I have seen?

[Nefaria]

Thanks for all the opinions. I was thinking around 3.0 to 4.0 to start with. I've seen some 4.5's that look very similar, those must have been gift grades. The spine has no splits and is 100% attached. If I had it to do all over again I'd have taken better care of it. But what the heck, an 11 year old kid back then certainly wasn't informed as to grade importance 43 years later.

[divad]

Thanks for all the opinions. I was thinking around 3.0 to 4.0 to start with. I've seen some 4.5's that look very similar, those must have been gift grades. The spine has no splits and is 100% attached. If I had it to do all over again I'd have taken better care of it. But what the heck, an 11 year old kid back then certainly wasn't informed as to grade importance 43 years later.

 

Nef,

 

One thing is apparent from the range of grades here: You will do just as well selling this book whether it is slabbed or not, as it's a tough book to find.

 

-d

[uclapeterg]

You guys are high . . . trust me on this one:

 

1.8 In the same league as my AF #15 and Spidey #1

 

(with obvious apologies to Arte and Aces)

 

 

umm, no.

[uclapeterg]

2.0/2.5.