Am I being OCD about case? 0

[EC Phanatic]

A few books I have gotten re holdered lately have had some debris inside the case. After sending these back,  one of the books came back with an almost one inch scratch on the lower left bottom. Every time I look at the cover I gravitate towards this scratch. Am I being too OCD about this or just let it go? Are all new cases "suppose" to be debris and scratch free? Even if it is a slight mark or scratch? 

[MadGenius]

A small scratch wouldn't bother me, but I guess "small" is subjective. I can't say I've experienced debris in the new case though.

[Kenners]

Here's some grass .. or nasal hair ..

[MustEatBrains]

I don't consider myself OCD at all with regards to CGC cases however I would draw the line on foreign body hair in my case.  Full stop.  

 

[porcupine48]

sixes and nines...

 

[MetalPSI]

 

[My young Padawan]

You are absolutely not being OCD about your expectations for a case that is without an eyesore.  As collectors, we expect our collections to be without flaws.  I have had three comic books returned to me in holders with stress cracks.  I will not be returning them.  It is simply not worth the hassle.  I would also not bother to return the one that Kenners has posted an image of.  It would not bother me that much, and it is simply not worth the hassle.  Good luck, Kelmonster1.

Stress Cracks?

Edited February 16, 2017 by My young Padawan

[Doc McCoy]

You're paying for a service.  If you aren't getting what you paid for, you most certainly aren't being OCD.  I wouldn't be happy with paying for a book to be graded/re-holdered and then having it returned with a scratch on the slab.