Pgm detective comics 359 0

[Ryanfromottawa]

Pgm detective comics 359

Hi, please give my your opinions as to the grade of this detective 359 , I've been meaning to send it off to get graded , just haven't gotten around to it..... thanks 

[ADAMANTIUM]

I would say somewhere around VF 8.0

[Payal Yusaf]

I'd say around 7.0  - 7.5.

[Bomber-Bob]

Nice book but a number of small problems. I'm at 7.5 tops. I just don't think it will make 8.0 .

[ADAMANTIUM]

5 minutes ago, Bomber-Bob said:

Nice book but a number of small problems. I'm at 7.5 tops. I just don't think it will make 8.0 .

Perhaps VF- I didn't really see cause I'm on my phone maybe even 7.0....still doesn't look too bad compared to the one's I've seen In person

 

Edited June 13, 2017 by ADAMANTIUM

[Bomber-Bob]

1 minute ago, ADAMANTIUM said:

Perhaps VF- I didn't really see spine ticks... So I didn't think it would go below VF or there abouts.... course I'm on my phone so perhaps I'm not seeing everything 

The bottom right corner has a significant impact ding with numerous creases, you can see it all the way through the BC. Large color breaking crease on the bottom edge. There are some spine ticks though I must admit the spine looks pretty good overall. The bottom left corner has some problems.

[ADAMANTIUM]

I see it now, that's an iffy place for me 7.0 sounds about right, but that spine looks fairly decent compared to the one's I've seen recently. 7.5 would be VF- one can hope  personally I think the spine looks to good to get 6.5 but that bottom right corner  may be worth a press since it doesn't seem to break color and IF they think the grade bump would be worth the cost...I don't have much experience with pressing, and I don't know if a press would make the crimp in the spine worse....or maybe just some encyclopedias on the corner?? I've had some flatten out that way, but I don't know how long it affects it or if the effects wear off...

Edited June 13, 2017 by ADAMANTIUM

[Ryanfromottawa]

Thx for the opinions folks, I plan on getting it sent off this month with a few others, what's a realistic turn around time with cgc these days?

[Readcomix]

My quick-glance knee-jerk was 7.0. On a slower pass, 7.5 won't surprise me either. Congrats either way! Bottom line, I grade it "lovely!" It's a great copy of a tough book!