Grade my Superman Ann. 7 please

[Comic Geek-migration]

 

 

[Red Hook]

7.0 , but a really nice looking 7.0.

[Mr. Zipper]

I think 7.0 is close, but I'd like to see the top edge which is cropped. There appears to be a small tear or impact that could drop it slightly.

 

Great book, BTW. I love the Superman Annuals.

[burntboy]

i'm thinking the back cover with it's dirt and ripples, will take this into the fine, fine plus range..............i, too, like these annuals with the cover photos on the BC, etc.

[Red Hook]

I saw the tear but didn't parse the fact that the top edge was cropped.

 

I must be losing my edge!

 

 

I love those DC 25c 80 pagers too!

[Comic Geek-migration]

 

here's a better scan of the top edge

 

[nik]

6.0/6.5 with that tear

[divad]

C'mon - it's a small tear Clean up the back cover, and you might get a 7.0 - it is an 80-pager

 

I'll give you 20 cents for it

[Mr. Zipper]

C'mon - it's a small tear Clean up the back cover, and you might get a 7.0 - it is an 80-pager

 

I dunno...

 

That top edge makes a BIG difference, IMO.

 

A ragged tear, impact dents and a few crescent creases... no better than 6.0 IMO...

[divad]

C'mon - it's a small tear Clean up the back cover, and you might get a 7.0 - it is an 80-pager

 

I dunno...

 

That top edge makes a BIG difference, IMO.

 

A ragged tear, impact dents and a few crescent creases... no better than 6.0 IMO...

 

Could be . . .

[Aces]

7.0

[Ron_Nasty]

A ragged tear, impact dents and a few crescent creases... no better than 6.0 IMO...

 

All magnified X number of times.

 

Nice comic.

[uclapeterg]

I think it's a 6.5/7.0. C'mon guys, are you truly that hard on your own books?