Please grade my WINGS COMICS 34 0

[Bird]

Another binder hole casualty! It looks to have been trimmed as well on the outer edge but is it possible that it was just horribly miscut? In any event, please grade my Wings Comics 34.

[mrlatko]

What is the consensus on binder holes affecting grade?  I don't know the answer.

[Bird]

2 minutes ago, mrlatko said:

What is the consensus on binder holes affecting grade?  I don't know the answer.

 On a previous wings it was just a qualified and then the regular grade I think 

[mrlatko]

2 minutes ago, Bird said:

 On a previous wings it was just a qualified and then the regular grade I think 

Right, but if not qualified, what would a 8.0 GA book receive with two clean hole punches through the book?  As high as a 4.0?

[Bomber-Bob]

Usually the edges were trimmed on Bound Books. If so, I would think the trimmed overrides a possible Qualified Label for the holes. If so, the flaws on a PLOD are counted against the grade. The spine on the Back cover looks more rough than the front cover. If only holes, I think I am looking at a Qualified 8.0 book. 

[1950's war comics]

you might be looking at a 5.0-6.0 green label .. here is an example of a comic with three ring binder punches..

Edited December 31, 2018 by 1950's war comics

[Bird]

Thanks everyone, although I may be more knowledgeable than when I started the thread I am definitely confused.