ComicSupply Grading Contest Round 8

[Aman619]

way to go October!! Fine showing! and a tough tough contest. I wish I got a bye, or tied once.... Good luck everybody still in it to win it!!

[toro]

Congratulations October!!!! Freakin fantastic that you nailed it too!!!

[toro]

Is the screaming room still open??? I really need to go there for this book!

 

I'll be doing that from the mega-losers area too!

[kiltman]

#33 Mr. Norinn A.K.A Thread starter theif. Yousa goin down!

 

Another one bites the dust.

[PedigreeMan]

Okay, this settles it. That new grading company that Lighthouse, Darth, and Donut are planning to start up needs to hire Andy as its HEAD GRADER. No questions asked. He'd dethrone Borock as King of the Comic World in about six months! (Plus the dude can pick out color touch at twenty paces. He must be able to smell the stuff!)

 

Congrats, Andy!

 

Alan

 

P.S. Go away, JC. Please. Or at least resume your Tango 'n Cash ID, as assuming his identity really seemed to temper your mood.

[Warlord]

Is the screaming room still open??? I really need to go there for this book!

 

I'll be doing that from the mega-losers area too!

 

What? Are you kidding? That was an easy 7.0!

 

I arrived there by remembering that the other MTUA #1 had large fugly creases and still got a 6.0. I figured in comparison this had to be at least a full point better

[october]

Is the screaming room still open??? I really need to go there for this book!

 

I'll be doing that from the mega-losers area too!

 

What? Are you kidding? That was an easy 7.0! tsk

 

I arrived there by remembering that the other MTUA #1 had large fugly creases and still got a 6.0. I figured in comparison this had to be at least a full point better

 

Don't give away the keys to victory! There are enemies all around.

[Mr. Zipper]

I arrived there by remembering that the other MTUA #1 had large fugly creases and still got a 6.0. I figured in comparison this had to be at least a full point better

 

I remembered the same fact, but arrived at a different conclusion.

 

The crease on the 6.0 was on the back cover and in a white area (hence, not so obvious of a colorbreak). And we've seen plenty of evidence that CGC is far more forgiving to flaws on the back cover as opposed to the front.

 

So, it was not unrealistic to think that the more recent book could have graded lower than the first. I think the first book certainly had much better eye appeal.

 

[Warlord]

Is the screaming room still open??? I really need to go there for this book!

 

I'll be doing that from the mega-losers area too!

 

What? Are you kidding? That was an easy 7.0! tsk

 

I arrived there by remembering that the other MTUA #1 had large fugly creases and still got a 6.0. I figured in comparison this had to be at least a full point better

 

Don't give away the keys to victory! There are enemies all around.

 

Don't worry, that wasn't the key. I left out a lot of the more important steps such as those including candles, incense, moonlight, and the use of a Ouija board precisely at midnight...