Captain America USA comics 0

[Redlinedog68]

This is one i had for some time..top right corner missing but other than that it seems really nice... any thoughts on what a grade would be..?

Im sure the corner probably kills it but would this be one for slabing ? 

[davet75]

gorgeous book, outstanding colors and gloss.  some spine and cover wear and creases (mostly non-CB), small area of color loss along spine, tiny tears on back cover, small stains, faint dust shadow on back cover, and of course the approx 1" triangular piece missing.

CGC 5.0  

[theCapraAegagrus]

4.0 IMO.

[Gnasher]

And I'm at the mean... 4.5. Pity about the missing piece, pretty solid otherwise.

[FoggyNelson]

4.0 very good👏👏🆒

[obiedagod]

4.0

[Redlinedog68]

Thanks all...i appreciate your time checking out my old books...helps me get a feel for grading these cool old pieces of history...-roger

[The Lions Den]

It has elements of both a Very Good and a Fine, so I like the 5.0...

[iXr184]

Sharp comic.

I would still get it cleaned and pressed before sending it out. 6.0 IMO. 

Edited April 15, 2019 by iXr184

[davet75]

On 4/11/2019 at 12:06 AM, davet75 said:

gorgeous book, outstanding colors and gloss.  some spine and cover wear and creases (mostly non-CB), small area of color loss along spine, tiny tears on back cover, small stains, faint dust shadow on back cover, and of course the approx 1" triangular piece missing.

CGC 5.0  

At the risk of being redundant (used these same examples for another nice GA book in PGM), i'll repost a few examples of CGC books with similar defects.  i.e beautifully presenting except for a piece out.

The OP's book has a larger piece out.  As an academic point of discussion, none of these books would grade over VG+ by Overstreet standards due to the missing piece, and that's a very important divergence in grading standards to understand if you're considering slabbing your books with missing pieces.