Please grade my Batman 25

[Bat-Hound]

[/img] How much would the corner crease downgrade this book? No other major flaws and has white pages! [/img]

[Norrin_Radd]

One of my favorites early Batmans!

 

As far as grade.... ..... around 6.5-7.0?

[Aces]

7.0

[casey1870]

yeah 7.0....maybe better...nice book though. Where did you pick that up at?

[skybolt]

I agree........7.0. Too bad about the crease, otherwise, it's an 8.0/8.5.

[Red Hook]

CGC is very tough on creases of that size. Otherwise a super book! Sweet!

[SignatureSelect]

6.5

[divad]

7.5 Sheesh! It's Batman #25 fergawdsake!!!

[sterlingcomics]

My GA grading needs work...haven't looked at the other grades....I'm thinking FN+ 6.5....

[dc eng]

7.0

[thedude]

dude, that is one sweet book, I'm thinking it would grade a 7.5 , due to the corner crease ......

[143ksk]

I would say it's an 8.5 without the crease, so 7.5 seems doable. Nice book

[Larryw7]

7.0

 

Beautiful book!

[Nefaria]

Batman on a Harley, maybe I need to read a DC comic some day

7.0 GA

[Bat-Hound]

CGC is very tough on creases of that size. Otherwise a super book! Sweet!

Thanks for some opinions on grading this book. I think Red Hooks comments are accurate when it comes to CGC grading. I had this book graded two years ago and to my shock came back a miserable 5.5 Blue label, white pages . I thought myself the book was a 7.0 due to cover gloss, nice corners, excellent spine and white pages. The corner crease is noticeable but does not break. I have seen dime size pieces out on otherwise 8.0 books and still get a 7.0 grade. What would you rather have a small piece out on the cover or a corner crease? I have many Golden age Batmans graded in the 7.0 to 9.0 by CGC and still consider this book rated with these. I don't think a will slab this book again because the corner crease in CGC opinion just kills the book

[herc2000]

5.0 crease is to big, better than your average book graded like that though.

[Amazing_Bag_man]

solid 6.5 - 7.0