Please Grade my DD#13

[Comicdey]

Let's see if you guys agree with how I've listed it up on Ebay.

 

Thanks for humoring me.

[herc2000]

Looks like a fn, fn+

[sterlingcomics]

I was going to say VF- 7.5 until I saw that top staple. FN+ 6.5 is my final.

[mica]

That's what I was going to say.

[casey1870]

That's what I was going to say.

Sure I'll go with that...where's the book

[Comicdey]

Hey guys,

 

Thanks for the opinions on grading,

 

The top staple is a deep one from the factory. There is no pop or tears there, so is this a factory defect that downgrades a VF- book to a Fine+?

 

I didn't even really consider it as a deduct when I graded it.

 

I figured that CGC wouldn't downgrade a factory production item like that, so I didn't either.

 

Opinions on this factory defect are welcome.

 

Thanks

[dc eng]

That's what I was going to say.

Sure I'll go with that...where's the book

 

 

6.0 / 6.5

 

[casey1870]

That's what I was going to say.

Sure I'll go with that...where's the book

 

 

6.0 / 6.5

 

 

Well thanks mordo! Appreciate it....

[sterlingcomics]

Hey guys,

 

Thanks for the opinions on grading,

 

The top staple is a deep one from the factory. There is no pop or tears there, so is this a factory defect that downgrades a VF- book to a Fine+?

 

I didn't even really consider it as a deduct when I graded it.

 

I figured that CGC wouldn't downgrade a factory production item like that, so I didn't either.

 

Opinions on this factory defect are welcome.

 

Thanks

 

A defect is a defect is a defect. My grade still stands.

[Comicdey]

I'm not arguing your grade. Just curious if CGC would downgrade for it at this point.

[KingOfRulers]

I'd call it a 7.5.

[Comicdey]

Thank you for one post of validation.

 

I was feeling a bit harshed on.

 

It just goes to show that everyone is entitled to an opinion.

 

Thanks again

[sterlingcomics]

Not hating on your book at all...Just giving the grade as I see it.

Feel free to send it to CGC to prove me wrong

 

I was in the bottom tier in the grading contest so you really shouldn't listen to my opinion at all...

[Comicdey]

Can't send it to CGC now, it's up and running on Ebay and is going for a whopping $3.26 right now with less than 5 days left. The link is posted in the marketplace.

 

Pretty good deal for even a F+ wouldn't you say?

[Comicdey]

"I was in the bottom tier in the grading contest so you really shouldn't listen to my opinion at all... "

 

Why didn't you tell me you couldn't grade in the first place?

 

I wouldn't have taken your criticism regarding the issue so hard.

 

You tainted the grading until Galactus (king of rulers) stepped up to the plate to agree with me.

 

2 out of 7 graders aggreeing that the book is a VF- is a majority consensus isn't it?

 

Either way it's gone in a few days.

 

Thanks for the opinions.

[nik]

7.0

[Aces]

6.5/7.0

[divad]

"I was in the bottom tier in the grading contest so you really shouldn't listen to my opinion at all... "

 

Why didn't you tell me you couldn't grade in the first place?

 

I wouldn't have taken your criticism regarding the issue so hard.

 

You tainted the grading until Galactus (king of rulers) stepped up to the plate to agree with me.

 

2 out of 7 graders aggreeing that the book is a VF- is a majority consensus isn't it?

 

Either way it's gone in a few days.

 

Thanks for the opinions.

 

6.0

 

VF-?

[Comicdey]

So maybe I overgraded this one a bit.

 

Thanks Nikos and Aces for the opinions. You guys usually target right on.

 

You too Divrabnud for stomping out the 6.0 opinion. I would have expected no less....and no more.

 

[Comicdey]

No one has yet to answer how CGC downgrades for the deep factory staple?