Please Grade MY Spook 23 0

[Black Bat]

I also have an ungraded Spook 23 laying around- years ago I graded it in my catalogue app, but I want to compare it to what you guys think.  I think I would also grade it different as grading seem to have "loosened" up a bit for GA books.  That is not a tear on the back cover left edge, its a stain but not water damage.  Thanks!!

Edited March 4, 2020 by Black Bat

[Point Five]

Nice! I'll say 5.0/5.5. Colors are purty.

 

[thehumantorch]

I'll swim in at 5.0

[William-James88]

4.5

[theCapraAegagrus]

5.5 IMO.

[SuperApe]

Interesting that some people gave yours a 5.5, and some gave mine a 6.0. Funny to see another copy! Not sure how rare it is, but you don't see many of them. Maybe people don't show them off very often as it's less dramatic than other LB Cole covers. I would give you a grade but I'm so out of touch, I'm hesitant. That's why I'm on here getting my books graded!

[BigDaddy1]

5.0

[Deadpoolica]

5.5

[ChrispyC66]

5.0