Should I grade these? 0

[Mart8925]

This Comic is Really Sharp, and If I am told a Major grade reduction will not occur, I plan on Pressing and grading it. It has a few very minor things. Looks great. The tear I can see the line at top, and inside I can see it. But I see no light in between the tear. It isn't separated. I just wondered if the tear was less than 1/4 inch. This one is 1/8 how much it would impact the Grade? The tear is not open, it is together, just the line visible. I also have an amazing Spider-Man 194 with a corner crease that breaks color. Wondered how much that takes off grade. If I can get a 7.0 or higher. Plan on pressing if can. Avengers 37 on top left corner has a scratch that doesn't really break much color. I wonder what you think. If pressed it would it get a 8.0 or higher? The rest of it is great. Last I have a Tales of Suspense 86 that has the Lower right corner cleanly cut by something like scissors. How much would that corner effect the grade. The comic is fantastic! Thanks for any feedback.

[Mart8925]

1st comic is my Avengers 83. Here are Pictures of the last two I talked about. Any feedback is appreciated. Thanks!

[oldrover]

If you want grade estimates, post these in the grading forum. And one per thread.

Welcome to the boards!

[Mart8925]

2 hours ago, oldrover said:

If you want grade estimates, post these in the grading forum. And one per thread.

Welcome to the boards!

 

[Mart8925]

Thanks!

[Mart8925]

1 hour ago, Will78 said:

Is that cover sun faded?

No, just the light above the Camera.

[revat]

you'll get more answers about the potential grades in the 'please grade my comic' area, but the question of 'should I grade these' is highly subjective and individual.  Without laying out your criteria for grading getting something graded, its hard for total strangers to provide you with useful advice.  Consider asking more specific questions and/or laying more specific criteria that matter to you.

Good luck

[Keys_Collector]

Yes grade them all and then be upset at what they grade at and then create a thread to complain about said grades.  Then disappear from the boards never to be seen again.  /end

[Mart8925]

Thanks!!