Question about CGC'ing comic with printing defect.

[ghengishahn]

Im looking at buying a silver age comic on ebay. However, there was a printing defect and the comic did not receive a bottom staple. If I send this comic to CGC, will this:

 

- Affect the overall grade? IIRC, printing defects dont, but I just want to make sure.

 

- Will this cause the comic to receive a qualified grade?

 

- Will this defect be listed in the "graders notes" of the CGC label?

 

Thanks for helping a newb out.

[Flaming_Telepath]

Im looking at buying a silver age comic on ebay. However, there was a printing defect and the comic did not receive a bottom staple. If I send this comic to CGC, will this:

 

- Affect the overall grade? IIRC, printing defects dont, but I just want to make sure.

 

- Will this cause the comic to receive a qualified grade?

 

- Will this defect be listed in the "graders notes" of the CGC label?

 

Thanks for helping a newb out.

 

Shouldn't effect the grade. I've got an Iron Man #1 in the old label and it's noted with 'manufactured with one staple'. However, I'm not even sure they note that sort of thing these days...

[divad]

Im looking at buying a silver age comic on ebay. However, there was a printing defect and the comic did not receive a bottom staple. If I send this comic to CGC, will this:

 

- Affect the overall grade? IIRC, printing defects dont, but I just want to make sure.

 

- Will this cause the comic to receive a qualified grade?

 

- Will this defect be listed in the "graders notes" of the CGC label?

 

Thanks for helping a newb out.

 

Shouldn't effect the grade. I've got an Iron Man #1 in the old label and it's noted with 'manufactured with one staple'. However, I'm not even sure they note that sort of thing these days...

 

Nik,

 

Effectively, it shouldn't affect the grade at all . . . the effect of such a printer's defect does not affect the book.

 

Affectionately,

 

-d

[marvelcollector]

The OCGG specifically allows a staple missing (at time of production) through

(including) 9.4. Above that it's a little vague...says "must have original staples"....

[Flaming_Telepath]

Im looking at buying a silver age comic on ebay. However, there was a printing defect and the comic did not receive a bottom staple. If I send this comic to CGC, will this:

 

- Affect the overall grade? IIRC, printing defects dont, but I just want to make sure.

 

- Will this cause the comic to receive a qualified grade?

 

- Will this defect be listed in the "graders notes" of the CGC label?

 

Thanks for helping a newb out.

 

Shouldn't effect the grade. I've got an Iron Man #1 in the old label and it's noted with 'manufactured with one staple'. However, I'm not even sure they note that sort of thing these days...

 

Nik,

 

Effectively, it shouldn't affect the grade at all . . . the effect of such a printer's defect does not affect the book.

 

Affectionately,

 

-d

 

David, do you know any other words where the 'f' is quite heavily stressed?

 

'Cause I know two...

 

[divad]

Im looking at buying a silver age comic on ebay. However, there was a printing defect and the comic did not receive a bottom staple. If I send this comic to CGC, will this:

 

- Affect the overall grade? IIRC, printing defects dont, but I just want to make sure.

 

- Will this cause the comic to receive a qualified grade?

 

- Will this defect be listed in the "graders notes" of the CGC label?

 

Thanks for helping a newb out.

 

Shouldn't effect the grade. I've got an Iron Man #1 in the old label and it's noted with 'manufactured with one staple'. However, I'm not even sure they note that sort of thing these days...

 

Nik,

 

Effectively, it shouldn't affect the grade at all . . . the effect of such a printer's defect does not affect the book.

 

Affectionately,

 

-d

 

David, do you know any other words where the 'f' is quite heavily stressed?

 

'Cause I know two...

 

 

[FFB]

Im looking at buying a silver age comic on ebay. However, there was a printing defect and the comic did not receive a bottom staple. If I send this comic to CGC, will this:

 

- Affect the overall grade? IIRC, printing defects dont, but I just want to make sure.

 

- Will this cause the comic to receive a qualified grade?

 

- Will this defect be listed in the "graders notes" of the CGC label?

 

Thanks for helping a newb out.

 

We've had this discussion before. Per Steve Borock, a silver age book manufactured with one staple can get as high as a 9.6. Books printed in 1980 or later get downgraded more harshly if they are printed with only one staple because it was far less common after 1980 for a book to be printed with only one staple.

[Red Hook]

That's a run-on sentence.

[FFB]

That's a run-on sentence.

 

No it isn't.

[ghengishahn]

Thanks all!

[nearmint]

Is your last name "er"?

[Norrin_Radd]

Is your last name "er"?

 

Wrong country.

[nearmint]

Is your last name "er"?

 

Wrong country.

 

And how are things in Zenn-La today?