US Shipping Only: OCTOBERFEST addendum: silver, keys, bronze, Four Colors, etc 4 4

[jharvey]

FF 25

4.5

$240

 

[Djohnson321]

29 minutes ago, october said:

FF 7

3.5

$220

Take

[gunsmokin]

18 minutes ago, jharvey said:

FF 25

4.5

$240

 

Thanks for saving me a pm 

[grebal]

1 hour ago, october said:

Secret Wars 8

9.0

$120

[arzach421]

3 hours ago, october said:

DC 100 Pager 19

9.0

$80

Killer copy. Back cover spine dent. 

 

[entalmighty1]

Would you take a return on a book I bought from somebody else that may have mentioned they got it from you, but may not have? I can definitely prove I got it from somebody else.

[october]

26 minutes ago, entalmighty1 said:

Would you take a return on a book I bought from somebody else that may have mentioned they got it from you, but may not have? I can definitely prove I got it from somebody else.

Well, it definitely depends on the book, or doesn't. Either way, but probably I would except if I didn't feel like it. Which I don't.

[Chaz G.]

[allthingskryptonite]

57 minutes ago, entalmighty1 said:

Would you take a return on a book I bought from somebody else that may have mentioned they got it from you, but may not have? I can definitely prove I got it from somebody else.

This is too much to ask for. If you are unhappy with the book, you should sort it out with the seller, you bought it from. 

[comicquant]

4 hours ago, entalmighty1 said:

Would you take a return on a book I bought from somebody else that may have mentioned they got it from you, but may not have? I can definitely prove I got it from somebody else.

I think most sellers would find this perfectly reasonable!

Edited March 11, 2021 by comicquant

[entalmighty1]

15 hours ago, allthingskryptonite said:

This is too much to ask for. If you are unhappy with the book, you should sort it out with the seller, you bought it from. 

What if @october possibly knows the original seller, but maybe he doesn't.  Isn't there some gray area here that allows for this circumstance?  I need immediate clarification, as I could really use the money right now.

[Savoyard23]

13 minutes ago, entalmighty1 said:

What if @october possibly knows the original seller, but maybe he doesn't.  Isn't there some gray area here that allows for this circumstance?  I need immediate clarification, as I could really use the money right now.

Unless I'm misunderstanding the situation, why don't you just sell the book, then?

[gunsmokin]

23 minutes ago, entalmighty1 said:

What if @october possibly knows the original seller, but maybe he doesn't.  Isn't there some gray area here that allows for this circumstance?  I need immediate clarification, as I could really use the money right now.

Wait a second.. you were serious about this?

[universal soldier]

I would think a PM is the better way to inquire about a topic like this instead of cryptic hypotheticals in the thread...

[pmWolf]

This has to be an inside joke of some kind. No way this is a serious thing....

[october]

45 minutes ago, entalmighty1 said:

What if @october possibly knows the original seller, but maybe he doesn't.  Isn't there some gray area here that allows for this circumstance?  I need immediate clarification, as I could really use the money right now.

Didn't we already discuss this? One more time, just to be clear:

If it's a book I may have owned but possibly not, from a seller I absolutely know but probably don't,  there is a 50/50 shot of a definite grey area.

But there is only a 10% chance of that. 

[october]

FF 9 and ASM 122 sold

[comicquant]

54 minutes ago, entalmighty1 said:

What if @october possibly knows the original seller, but maybe he doesn't.  Isn't there some gray area here that allows for this circumstance?  I need immediate clarification, as I could really use the money right now.

The only well known aspect of this is how we've defined "possibly knows".  The accepted terms are the following:

1. At least one individual within the party has seen the other within the last 10 years.  No eye contact is necessary.
2. At least one individual within the party has spent 7 minutes in the other's last 3 most recent zip codes.
3. At least one individual within the party attended grammar school with someone the other individual has known with the last 10 years.
4. At least one individual within the party has shipped or received a comic within the "common zone".
5. At least one individual within the party can skip a rock 7 or more times.

If I remember correctly, those are the agreed upon rules; with the exception of #5 which I made up.

[october]

42 minutes ago, comicquant said:

4. At least one individual within the party has shipped or received a comic within the "common zone".
 

The Common Zone is crucial when deciding these difficult cases. I live in Nashville and he lives in Memphis (Nashville's smaller, uglier, dirtier little brother who also smells) so that might count. 

[entalmighty1]

1 hour ago, october said:

The Common Zone is crucial when deciding these difficult cases. I live in Nashville and he lives in Memphis (Nashville's smaller, uglier, dirtier little brother who also smells) so that might count. 

1. How dare you?

b) I decided to keep the book.  You don't even deserve my return.