PGM batman 238

[jokersrevenge]

[Aces]

6.0 maybe...

[Tomega]

4.5

[trevorlsmith]

5.0

[john72tex]

5.5 Definitely a mid grade book and one hard to find in high grade.

[Psiknight]

5.5/6.0.

 

I'd be shocked if this came back less than a 5.5 (let alone a 4.5!)

[Rip]

If CGC grades this as generous as most 100 pagers I'd say 6.5/7.0.

My grade 6.0

[divad]

4.5

 

Bingo!

[marvelcollector]

5.0

[KingOfRulers]

4.5

 

Bingo!

 

Dang. 6.5 from me.

[october]

5.0 or 5.5 sounds about right. Lot of different grades offered on this book.

[KingOfRulers]

Strange too. I think everyone should look on page 216 of the OS grading guide. That 7.0 which is on that page has almost the exact same defects of this book. I think you guys hammered away at this book.

[october]

Strange too. I think everyone should look on page 216 of the OS grading guide. That 7.0 which is on that page has almost the exact same defects of this book. I think you guys hammered away at this book.

 

Good call.

[divad]

Strange too. I think everyone should look on page 216 of the OS grading guide. That 7.0 which is on that page has almost the exact same defects of this book. I think you guys hammered away at this book.

 

Good call.

 

Waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay too much goin' on for a 7.0 - tear that page out and burn it!

 

btw, what book is on page 216?

[KingOfRulers]

Strange too. I think everyone should look on page 216 of the OS grading guide. That 7.0 which is on that page has almost the exact same defects of this book. I think you guys hammered away at this book.

 

Good call.

 

Waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay too much goin' on for a 7.0 - tear that page out and burn it!

 

btw, what book is on page 216?

 

Hey, I didn't write it! How about you call Mr. Overstreet and tell him exactly what you think of his crappy grading system. What's even funnier is that the book on pg 216 looks worse than this book There is more damage on the spine and an extra dog ear.

 

By the way the book is "Weird Science Fantasy Annual".

[october]

 

By the way the book is "Weird Science Fantasy Annual".

 

Now you are going to hear the ubiquitous "golden age curve" excuse.

[divad]

 

By the way the book is "Weird Science Fantasy Annual".

 

Now you are going to hear the ubiquitous "golden age curve" excuse.

 

and then some

[Rip]

I agree. Zero chance of anything below 5.5, unless we are missing something