Action Comics 65 Should I submit? 2 2

[mysterymachine]

Is this book worth submitting? A big chunk is missing at the staple. Otherwise its a nice book with off white/white pages. I'm hoping for 6.5 qualified. There is also a small tear under the price tag and staining on the back.  What do you think?

[mysterymachine]

I just noticed a big tear seal on the inside top of the book. I guess 6.5 is out of the question. What grade do think it will get?

[Galen130]

I wouldn't, but that's me.  Unless you want to preserve it in a slab for your PC, this one might be better in a GA/SA mylar with board. 

[mysterymachine]

Yeah that's what I'm thinking. I wish I noticed that tear seal before I posted. What grade would this get if the glue was removed?

[Randall Ries]

On 2/17/2022 at 1:33 PM, mysterymachine said:

I just noticed a big tear seal on the inside top of the book. I guess 6.5 is out of the question. What grade do think it will get?

It'll get a 3.0 purple label.

[grendelbo]

On 2/17/2022 at 4:43 PM, Randall Ries said:

It'll get a 3.0 purple label.

I'm too at 3.0. I guess a tear has been sealed on the back cover?

Thanks for sharing.

[mysterymachine]

On 2/17/2022 at 3:56 PM, grendelbo said:

I'm too at 3.0. I guess a tear has been sealed on the back cover?

Thanks for sharing.

Yes, the tear starts at the back and merges onto the front. You can see it better from the inside cover.

[Februus]

Yeah you don’t want a purple. I also am not a fan of the qualified label. If you want to sell it the green is a “what if” and a lot of collectors/investors shy away. If you can get a blue take it if not save your money Mylar it and disclose the resto to the buyer.. for what it’s worth that’s my view. 

[mysterymachine]

On 2/17/2022 at 7:41 PM, Februus said:

Yeah you don’t want a purple. I also am not a fan of the qualified label. If you want to sell it the green is a “what if” and a lot of collectors/investors shy away. If you can get a blue take it if not save your money Mylar it and disclose the resto to the buyer.. for what it’s worth that’s my view. 

Thanks. I'm putting together my next submission of about 12 books and have decided not to send this book. Thank you everyone for responding. I will be posting a few of my other candidates later today.