Lets grade some GA I am sick of moderns and common silver

[mstryinspc-migration]

one thing my scanner makes these books look really dirty they are not I don't know why.

 

[KingOfRulers]

Plastic Loser 24: 5.5

 

Smash Comics: 4.5

[mstryinspc-migration]

Plastic Loser 24: 5.5

 

Smash Comics: 4.5

 

I don't take opinions of Marvel loving everthing else bashers

[KingOfRulers]

I grade the book, not the title.

 

You could have a commie magazine featuring Hilary Clinton in a two piece, I'd still go by OS standards.

[mstryinspc-migration]

I grade the book, not the title.

 

You could have a commie magazine featuring Hilary Clinton in a two piece, I'd still go by OS standards.

 

do the words plastic LOSER come to mind or did you not say that? That is title bashing

[divad]

1) Good idea

 

2) Your scans are too small

 

3) Scanners never lie

[CJ]

1--5.5

 

2--4.5

 

I always liked old PM covers

[mstryinspc-migration]

1) Good idea

 

2) Your scans are too small

 

3) Scanners never lie

 

1 What is a good idea?

 

2 next you'll complain they are too big!

 

3 who said they lie people do!

[Jeffro.]

 

2) Your scans are too small

 

 

agreed, bigger scans please

[Timulty]

Dude, anyone who bashes Plas has to go through me. I would say 5.5-6.0 for Plastic Man and 4.5-5.0 for Smash. Is it alright if I drop my Police Comics 75 on this thread mstryincyberspc?

[divad]

1) Good idea

 

2) Your scans are too small

 

3) Scanners never lie

 

1 What is a good idea?

 

2 next you'll complain they are too big!

 

3 who said they lie people do!

 

How old are you? 12?

[Aces]

Plastic Loser 24: 5.5

 

Smash Comics: 4.5

 

Ditto, except the loser comment.

[mstryinspc-migration]

Dude, anyone who bashes Plas has to go through me. I would say 5.5-6.0 for Plastic Man and 4.5-5.0 for Smash. Is it alright if I drop my Police Comics 75 on this thread mstryincyberspc?

 

please doo

[Timulty]

Here it is:

 

 

Sorry for the size guys. If anyone knows of a utility or something I can resize this with, please let me know.

[CJ]

what grade did cgc give the police comics

 

I am guessing 5.0

[Timulty]

It will surprise you.

[CJ]

5.5?????? or even higher

[Timulty]

6.0, but since I cracked it will probably only get a 4.5 now. As a note, I think it is a pretty dirty copy. But the back is better and no, I don't have a scan of it.

[CJ]

wow 6.0--I think a grader was ill that day. To bad you cracked it

[Timulty]

I cracked it because yee olde scanner couldn't scan it. It was reholdered just before I received it, though I don't think that would have got it regraded. I have not removed inner holder. I will probably send it in, when I get an upgrade copy.