Other than a No.1 or First Appearance, what book of your Favorite Character would you like to own? 3 3

[Ken Aldred]

On 9/26/2023 at 9:59 PM, Sweet Lou 14 said:

Thanks.  But also, isn't this Curt Swan?

Swan’s Superman was quite chunky as well.

[Cat]

I'd choose All-star Comics #8, BUT not because of why you'd think. I want it because it's when Starman and Dr Mid-Nite join the JSA, and they're two of my favourite members. The issue is just sadly outshone by some Wonder Bread, or Wandy Woman, I dunno. 

My other choice would be Fantastic Four #51, This Man, This Monster. Such a great issue. I've got a nice statue based on it it'd display nicely with. 

[Chaz G.]

Detective #395, the first pairing of O'Neil & Adams. There's a CGC 9.0 out there signed by both that I hope to own . . . one day.

 

[OtherEric]

I would choose All-American Comics #16, it's easily the most difficult Scribbly appearance to track down.

I've actually got the Scribbly story from the Big All-American Comic Book as tear sheets, I would love to get the Scribbly story from AA 16 the same way if that's the only way I can find it.

[Readcomix]

Cap 46