PGM Life with Archie #6 w/ spine tear 0

[Pukie]

Thank you for your time helping to grade this book. 

There is a hole or tear on the spine adjacent to the staple.  Not along the staple length itself.  Would you call this a staple tear, spine tear, or..?

[vheflin]

Dunno what they'd call the tear, I'd call it a spine tear as it runs along the spine and not across the cover as staple tears do.

6.0 crow

[scburdet]

Not sure the definition of the tear matters much. It might even be an "acceptable" defect given the overall condition. The paper oxidation is pretty heavy. 5.5/6.0

[Pukie]

Thank you!

[Q.N.S.]

Wow, you guys are grading high. I wouldn't even consider putting this anything near fine condition. 

I have many books like this I grade as VG.. There are other significant issues here not just that staple rip. 

Edited Thursday at 04:31 PM by Q.N.S.

[Pukie]

Thank you!