Guess the CGC grade: divad's Doctor Strange #169

[divad]

 

 

[marvelcollector]

I'm guessing 7.5, but at this microscopic level it's hard to judge...might actually be a 9.4..

 

Geez, and you think my posts are large?

 

[mar-vell]

call it a CGC 7.5 --If I were grading it myself i might call it a 7.0 but definitely not an 8.0!

[JuliusSeizure]

I'll guess 6.0.

[Freddy-G.-migration]

6.5

[Comicdey]

7.0 CGC

 

6.5 comicdey

[SuperBird]

6.5

[KingOfRulers]

6.5

[Pirate]

6.0. scan is a bit small so we can't see all the imperfections

[divad]

6.0. scan is a bit small so we can't see all the imperfections

[divad]

 

[divad]

I'm guessing 7.5, but at this microscopic level it's hard to judge...might actually be a 9.4..

 

Geez, and you think my posts are large?

 

 

Kudos to the Marvel Twins for nailing it! See, it's tough to READ large scans . . .

[KingOfRulers]

. Seems overgraded to me. I thought my 6.5 was conservative though. If it were in my collection I would have said 7.0.

[divad]

. Seems overgraded to me. I thought my 6.5 was conservative though. If it were in my collection I would have said 7.0.

 

Seems undergraded to me . . . I think the top edge crease is rather insignificant from a bigger picture point of view . . . It's got a lot of positives

 

Seriously, I think the grade is right on, and that the boys in Sarasota do a bang-up job

[uclapeterg]

I guessed 7.5 be4 I saw the slab.. no, really!

[Timulty]

The Grading Bastiche say....you should be happy with 7.5.

[burntboy]

yet more compelling documentation that CGC grades Marvels easier......

[Timulty]

Agreed, Burntboy!!!

[RDK]

yet more compelling documentation that CGC grades Marvels easier......

 

After getting back my Bat 232 (9.0) I'm tempted to agree, but are there any theories as to why this is?

[Aces]

7.0

 

You got lucky with that big crease up top!