Grading Help Please....

[awe4one]

Since you all are so strict on grading others comics, I'll jump into the fray and be slaughtered. What do you think CGC would rate this at (one of twelve that arrived in my mailbox today)?

 

 

 

Jim

[murph0]

Potentially a VF/NM without seeing the back cover, do you have a scan?

 

Brian

[chrisco37]

Hard to say w/out back cover scan...but looks like easy 8.5....nice book!

 

Chris

[ArAich]

Gotta love those Dr. Strange covers.... ...I'm thinking 9.0 possibly 9.2 ...but the edge near the top staple looks a little frayed...nice book none-the-less...

[sfilosa]

So far 8.5-9.0. Seems to have a slight corner crease at the top right corner.

 

If that is correct, that probably excludes it from a 9.2 (maybe). And then in that case, I'm not sure it would be worth getting graded. Your going to pay between $25-30 to get it graded and the book could go for $45-60 (if it comes back as a 9.0).

 

 

[awe4one]

As requested, some bigger scans and the back cover for your amusement....

 

 

 

 

Thanks,

Jim

[murph0]

Thanks, I'm going to go with VF+. The back cover shows some real slight spine indents that aren't that big of a deal but enough to put it under VF/NM IMO as well as a slightly rounded lower bindary corner.

 

Brian

[doyle033]

my guess is 8.5 maybe 9.0 depending on someones day!!

good luck

[OldGuy]

9.2

[Crackandpresstoan11]

At least a 9.0, no better than 9.2. Don't believe all the haters @ 8.5.

[ubiquiti]

I'd give it a 9.0