CGC FORUM TOP BRONZE AGE COVERS - #9

[jbud73]

The 9th Place Cover sees the Zombies continue their assault on the Top 20 and also sees one of the most classic combos in comics hit the Poll. John Romita drawing the Amazing Spider-man - it doesn't get much better than that. Oh yes it does, throw in the Green Goblin and now your talking.

 

Thanks to CGC_World, THE_BEYONDER and Capt. Red Pants himself for nominating this book. No write ups you slackers , well this cover does speak for itself though.

 

[OldGuy]

Weak cover IMO.

[Sal]

another cover i don't see the appeal in.

 

what a mishmash. where did the street go to? oh, it would have been way too busy to have the buildings actually end in something, rather than just float there?

 

okey-dokey

[october]

Boy, JC's prediction of the "DC fanboys" owning the top 20 has really come true so far. I think he picked the wrong group of blind loyalists.

[october]

another cover i don't see the appeal in.

 

what a mishmash. where did the street go to? oh, it would have been way too busy to have the buildings actually end in something, rather than just float there?

 

okey-dokey

 

They are walking on a red hill that defies gravity that floats horizontally over the top of New York city?

[Sal]

another cover i don't see the appeal in.

 

what a mishmash. where did the street go to? oh, it would have been way too busy to have the buildings actually end in something, rather than just float there?

 

okey-dokey

 

They are walking on a red hill that defies gravity that floats horizontally over the top of New York city?

 

i thought it was a tomato?

[october]

another cover i don't see the appeal in.

 

what a mishmash. where did the street go to? oh, it would have been way too busy to have the buildings actually end in something, rather than just float there?

 

okey-dokey

 

They are walking on a red hill that defies gravity that floats horizontally over the top of New York city?

 

i thought it was a tomato?

 

Good call. Maybe. That still doesn't explain why the bottoms of the buildings are covered by yellow fog or pee or something.

[TeddieMercede]

It looks like Marvels are going to do fairly well in the next 8 covers but this cover seems lacking to me also. All I know is GL 76 better be top 3 if this is #9.

[divad]

Boy, JC's prediction of the "DC fanboys" owning the top 20 has really come true so far. I think he picked the wrong group of blind loyalists.

 

I think that the phrase JC's prediction speaks for itself . . .

[RDK]

YUCK!. Don't see the APPEAL of this one at ALL!

[october]

Boy, JC's prediction of the "DC fanboys" owning the top 20 has really come true so far. I think he picked the wrong group of blind loyalists.

 

I think that the phrase JC's prediction speaks for itself . . .

 

Touche!

[divad]

Well, it's starting to look like I'm either going to ACE the top five . . . or get shut out entirely!

[mica]

The Green Lantern book, and the Batman book will be there. Dc fans needn't worry.

[divad]

The Green Lantern book, and the Batman book will be there. Dc fans needn't worry.

 

Uh, which Batman would that be?

[mica]

The Green Lantern book, and the Batman book will be there. Dc fans needn't worry.

 

Uh, which Batman would that be?

The one that's a tribute to the old Detective comics cover. Large batman looking down.....etc..

[Sal]

better?

 

 

 

[october]

You missed a spot by Harry's leg.

[Scheradon]

I'm would fall under the Marvel fanboy label, but didn't vote for this book. I don't know, just nothing standing out to me.

 

I think it's the whole hissy fight going on beneath Spidey and the GG that feels more like a distraction to me.

[Sal]

You missed a spot by Harry's leg.

 

i saw that as i put it up. oh well.

 

tell you what, doing that photoshopping really gives you an idea of how screwed up the whole Goblin Glider is on this cover. plus, Gobby's right leg seems to be missing from knee to ankle

[mica]

It's always sad to see former room-mates fight.