CGC FORUM TOP BRONZE AGE COVERS - #1

[Comicdey]

Ok, lets see the whole list and points given.

[divad]

Completely derivative . . . on two counts, and hastily executed. :thumbs down:

 

Hey, we actually agree on something!

 

I suspect we agree on a lot more than that!

[Sal]

to me this book belongs in the top 20 but not the top 10 for 2 reasons:

1) the original(tec 31) is completely superior

2) the colors of the characters in the foreground are all wrong, in fact i think you have a better cover if they aren't even present!

 

still a cool cover-even though i am a marvelite i do think DC had the edge in cover art during the bronze age thanks to adams -i just don't think this is the best example!

 

oh, i dunno about that...

 

[mar-vell]

to me this book belongs in the top 20 but not the top 10 for 2 reasons:

1) the original(tec 31) is completely superior

2) the colors of the characters in the foreground are all wrong, in fact i think you have a better cover if they aren't even present!

 

still a cool cover-even though i am a marvelite i do think DC had the edge in cover art during the bronze age thanks to adams -i just don't think this is the best example!

 

oh, i dunno about that...

 

 

--at the very least he needed to do something differently with the foreground because it does look a little plain without the characters! just look at the original--now there is a true masterpiece! the characters blend so much better!

[shiverbones]

hahaha brilliant!

[Weird]

Now get rid of the Robin blurb and make Bat's ears the same size.

[divad]

Now get rid of the Robin blurb and make Bat's ears the same size.

 

why not?

[nearmint]

I've always thought that the Robin blurb took away from this cover.

[blowout]

Completely derivative . . . on two counts, and hastily executed. :thumbs down:

 

Hey, we actually agree on something!

 

This is the best cover that the Bronze Age has to offer? I don't think you'll find too many takers for that proposition outside of the narrow group on this Forum who voted.

 

Agree completely. A weak Adams cover in my opinion.

[october]

Completely derivative . . . on two counts, and hastily executed. :thumbs down:

 

Hey, we actually agree on something!

 

This is the best cover that the Bronze Age has to offer? I don't think you'll find too many takers for that proposition outside of the narrow group on this Forum who voted.

 

Agree completely. A weak Adams cover in my opinion.

 

Adams newbie!

[Sal]

Now get rid of the Robin blurb and make Bat's ears the same size.

 

your wish...yadda yadda yadda

 

[mica]

I've always thought that the Robin blurb took away from this cover.

[october]

[blowout]

Completely derivative . . . on two counts, and hastily executed. :thumbs down:

 

Hey, we actually agree on something!

 

This is the best cover that the Bronze Age has to offer? I don't think you'll find too many takers for that proposition outside of the narrow group on this Forum who voted.

 

Agree completely. A weak Adams cover in my opinion.

 

Adams newbie!

 

Adams zombie!!

[october]

Completely derivative . . . on two counts, and hastily executed. :thumbs down:

 

Hey, we actually agree on something!

 

This is the best cover that the Bronze Age has to offer? I don't think you'll find too many takers for that proposition outside of the narrow group on this Forum who voted.

 

Agree completely. A weak Adams cover in my opinion.

 

Adams newbie!

 

Adams zombie!!

 

Marvel zombie!!!

[Sal]

[october]

ROFL!

[Sal]

it was the natural culmination of that line of conversation, i think

 

[Darrell F]

That is some great photoshop work guys

[blowout]

Completely derivative . . . on two counts, and hastily executed. :thumbs down:

 

Hey, we actually agree on something!

 

This is the best cover that the Bronze Age has to offer? I don't think you'll find too many takers for that proposition outside of the narrow group on this Forum who voted.

 

Agree completely. A weak Adams cover in my opinion.

 

Adams newbie!

 

Adams zombie!!

 

Marvel zombie!!!

 

Which one of us cast all their votes for the same publisher I wonder?