Please Grade My FF 5

[Comicdey]

Note no marvel chipping

[thedarkknight]

VERY FINE (8.0)

[Anfield Fox]

 

VFN-

[-cryptkeeper-]

agree with 7.5 , really nice

[joeypost]

7.5. Aaaargggh on the writing on FC. Sweet bunch of books lately. Most have been some income tax refund.

[weaponx]

Nice book. 7.5

 

[Kermit the frog]

 

i'm really hesitating on this one between the 7.5 and 8.0...what the heck it should get a 8.0 with such glossy/eye appealing cover and structurally with no important flaws!!!

beautiful!!!

how are the interior pages?!

 

regards

[scupbucket]

8.0

[KingOfRulers]

7.0

[marvelcollector]

7.5

[Aces]

You guys missing that crease/tear on the "S" in Fantastic?

 

6.5 if it's a tear

7.0 if it's a crease

 

[Kermit the frog]

You guys missing that crease/tear on the "S" in Fantastic?

 

6.5 if it's a tear

7.0 if it's a crease

 

 

indeed i didn't saw it...yep it's an 1 point drop unfornutelly (in case to be a crease, which it's what it looks like).

 

thanks for pointing out Aces.

 

regards

[Amazing_Bag_man]

very nice...solid 7.0!!

[rjpb]

You guys missing that crease/tear on the "S" in Fantastic?

 

6.5 if it's a tear

7.0 if it's a crease

 

 

6.0 if it's a tear.

[-cryptkeeper-]

You guys missing that crease/tear on the "S" in Fantastic?

 

6.5 if it's a tear

7.0 if it's a crease

 

[Comicdey]

Not a crease, not a tear, it's a scuff.

 

So now what is it?

[-cryptkeeper-]

Not a crease, not a tear, it's a scuff.

 

So now what is it?

 

it's a gem

[Aces]

Not a crease, not a tear, it's a scuff.

 

So now what is it?

Damn scrape!

Somebody wasn't careful!

 

7.0

[Psiknight]

7.0

 

The pen is what makes this book simply great instead of extraordinary. Well, it might still be extraordinary!

[uclapeterg]

6.5.