PGM Swamp Thing #10

[alecholland]

I think it's a 9.2. But that might be wishful thinking on my part. It's probably an 8.5. Here are the links:

 

Front

 

Back

[october]

9.2. Too bad about the back cover corner bend. Without that the book is a 9.6.

[Timulty]

The Grading Bastiche says .... 9.0. Man, that back corner bend is bad enough to drop it out of 9.2. Got to say, nice bright colors, really sharp everywhere else. Maybe, I am just being too harsh.

[alecholland]

Maybe, I am just being too harsh.

 

I don't think so. I thought it might only be an 8.5 because of the bend on the back cover corner. Everything else about it is just so dang nice. Looks brand spankin' new.

[october]

Maybe, I am just being too harsh.

 

I don't think so. I thought it might only be an 8.5 because of the bend on the back cover corner. Everything else about it is just so dang nice. Looks brand spankin' new.

 

No way that book is only an 8.5. That bend is really the only defect. Sharp copy!

[Sal]

Maybe, I am just being too harsh.

 

I don't think so. I thought it might only be an 8.5 because of the bend on the back cover corner. Everything else about it is just so dang nice. Looks brand spankin' new.

 

No way that book is only an 8.5. That bend is really the only defect. Sharp copy!

 

that ncb on the BC between the bottom staple and the BE, the ULBC and the two other miniscule ncbs on the back spine make this a 9.0.

 

again i am reminded why grading from a scan is just useless...this is a perfect book to grade in hand to get an accurate sense of the defects