PGM Showcase 24

[SteveLRoberts5]

[SteveLRoberts5]

Here's the back cover to Showcase 24:

[CJ]

Easy 9.0 from everything I see with the scans

 

AWSOME looking issue.

[action1kid]

7.5

[MCMiles]

8.0

[burntboy]

one of the very few DC's from the late 50's that somehow escaped my clutches....

 

the FC is very nice and i would tend to agree with a 9.0 based on it alone, but the visible spine stresses on the BC along with the tiny stain on the BC bottom edge, will likely pull this down to a 7.5 - 8.0............

 

i was looking at my Atom #2 the other day (before saying so long to it), which CGC graded a 9.0 and it has far fewer defects overall................

 

having said all this, this book would look fine in any collection...... .....

(except Tim's of course.............)

[The Troll King]

 

I'm having a really hard time agreeing with a 9.0 on this.

 

I'm seeing a 7.0-7.5

 

All of the edges have some wear. The amount of NCB spine creases alone would being this below a 9.0

 

A little dirty also.

 

Plus, I'm not sure what that is going on at the bottom of the back image. I can't tell if it's an impact crease, a stain, or some sort of moisture damage. If this is a 9.0 then I'm seriously undergrading a lot of books!