Guess the CGC grade: Superman #11...

[nik]

Wow, grades from 2.5 to 5.5.

 

Somewhere higher then a 2.5 and lower then a 5.5

 

[divad]

Wow, grades from 2.5 to 5.5.

 

Yes, except that I'm in good company . . .

[Point Five]

Thanks for all the grades, guys. Obviously the stain made this one very tough to call, but that's the fun of it!

 

Big props to Buffyfan, uclapeterg, svndst1030, october and Aces for the correct answer, and to others of you for even coming close! With such a fundamentally large and ugly stain I would never have dreamed of calling this higher than 3.0, but here you go...shows you what I know!

 

[Aces]

I got one right?

[divad]

 

So what was the restoration? Is this the new label designation? No level of restoration? No description of work done? Whether it was slight or extensive? Amateur or professional?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Because we ALL know that trimming is NOT restoration

[uclapeterg]

I got one right?

 

you graded all over the place..wishy washy

[143ksk]

Thanks for all the grades, guys. Obviously the stain made this one very tough to call, but that's the fun of it!

 

Big props to Buffyfan, uclapeterg, svndst1030, october and Aces for the correct answer, and to others of you for even coming close! With such a fundamentally large and ugly stain I would never have dreamed of calling this higher than 3.0, but here you go...shows you what I know!

 

 

That book doesn't look to better than a 5.5 without the waterstain. I can't believe it only got bumped down 1.5. I know I would be pissed if I got that as a VG. Well, unless I had submitted it

[Sal]

 

So what was the restoration? Is this the new label designation? No level of restoration? No description of work done? Whether it was slight or extensive? Amateur or professional?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Because we ALL know that trimming is NOT restoration

 

bah.

 

CGC hasn't worked up an appropriate colour label for trimming. since trimming isn't restoration, it gets no notations aside from the trimming one, and doesn't get any A or P designations.

 

but you knew that and just are being snarky.

[divad]

Yeah . . . I was in a snarky mood

[burntboy]

I got one right?

 

you graded all over the place..wishy washy

 

yup, ACES would have gotten it "Right" if it had graded 3.0, 3.5, 4.0, 4.5 or 5.0